I was a Gnome 2 user back in the day and then used KDE for a while. After some Linux-Desktop-Pause I installed Mint and used Cinnamon for a couple of yrs, so I’ve tested thru the bank. As I switched back to my beloved Debian I tried out the Gnome 3 UI in Buster for the first time. I find the Gnome 3 UI actually refreshing and different. I figured out that I was, after yrs of Linux usage, still trying to think of Linux Desktop in a way that it should be “Windows-like” in appearance. No need for that! People over at Gnome are trying new stuff and this is good! Cinnamon is a great DE, but Gnome 3 doesn’t deserve the bashing it gets.
these blog posts are always just the repeating well-known comparision talking points (xfce: light, other: not). just like hundred other blogs.
Are live boot screenshots and RAM usage all there is about these DEs?
Well, other differences usually go very deep into the details and are ultimately a matter of taste. It’s certainly not the case that all of these have a unique selling point, because well, they’re not products trying to sell themselves.
Having said that, these are the high-level differences as I see them:
Cinnamon:
- Very Windows-like (aesthetics and keyboard shortcuts)
- one polished workflow
- covers relatively many exotic usage scenarios relatively well
MATE:
- relatively lightweight
- one polished workflow
Xfce:
- relatively lightweight
- very modular and customizable
i would say the target reader is people who haven’t read all the other hundred other blogs
On GNOME 3.x now, really settled into it. I have heard claims that KDE is more efficient on resources than Xfce. Is there any truth to this? If so what are the significant differences or why this is?
deleted by creator
I wonder why they don’t have a LXDE flavor. I used ~2006 era core2duos with some gma950 and 2 gb of ram until a few years ago. The performance of Lubuntu was unparalleled.
deleted by creator
I honestly can’t use anything else.
deleted by creator
nobody is talking about fvwm in these days… :-(
I got tired of the broken theming experience and lack of wayland support any time soon on their roadmap.
I also found myself preferring apps that were built for GNOME anyway, so I ended up making a silly XFCE GNOME hybrid. All of my computers have decent graphics/ram and the resource usage of GNOME is overstated.
deleted by creator
XFCE Window Manager & GTK themes are different
deleted by creator
Also I don’t think it will be 20 years before Wayland is usable. I am using it right now on Manjaro Gnome and it works better than X.
GNOME
deleted by creator
