• @PP44
    link
    22 years ago

    I agree : the question, if it is one seeking an actual answer, is a bad one. But I guess we can be more charitable and view this question purely as a conversation starter around an issue. Maybe OP wants to have the view of a wide number of people around this subject one general, and purposefully makes questions as imprecise as possible. If I am not mistaken, I saw other questions of the same type by OP before.

    • erpicht
      link
      32 years ago

      I mean to call attention to the fact that that this type of question is difficult to engage with precisely due to the fact that it is unfocused and lacks context.

      The onus is on those answering to interpret when and where both ancient and modern fall, what constitutes slavery, compare the generalized forms of slavery in two times and places chosen, figure out how the differences stack up, and finally type the conclusion up in the form of an answer. That’s quite a burden placed upon the would-be answer-er to provide any sort of meaningful reply.

      It is of course possible to provide unfocused, un-contextual, hasty replies, but if the question does not seek a meaningful answer, why should anyone bother to engage with it? Though as a conversation starter it performs poorly too, because people have to puzzle out what the question even means to ask before anything else.

      • @PP44
        link
        32 years ago

        I once again I mostly agree with your critics here. Those are valid critics if such a question. But I would not go as far as you do. You talk about “burden”, but nobody is forced to engage in a discussion they don’t see as useful. And all the details needed to be able to even start a discussions about the subject launch can be the focus of the discussion if anyone would like it to be.

        Even this discussion we are having about what is a valid way to ask about something is something interesting, and I’m sure OP is OK with people getting so far off.

        This situation is different from someone “hijacking” a specific conversation, if this conversation was started by people that wanted to tackle a specific issue.

        Anyway, this question is, I agree, impossible to answer here in a few word. I would need a whole book or even a career to study it. I am both unable and unwilling to give an6 relevant answer on it, that is OK. But if someone want to shower OP with pertinent sources, or interesting critisicm, I am perfectly OK with it !

    • @tomaszOP
      link
      -12 years ago

      Correct assumption. I just like how people differently approach these questions. They are really general, I agree, but that’s what I like in them and answers some are trying to add.