In security, you can’t assume that the the server isn’t storing a piece of data just because the operator says it isn’t
100% agree with you about being unable to confirm what the server is doing, but the fact of the matter is anyone you interact with - centralized server-client or decentralized peer-to-peer - can store some metadata.
The FBI could force Moxie to hand it over, and may have already done so without us knowing
Private contact discovery is engineered in a way that you would be unable to retrieve what is being processed even if you had access to Signal’s infrastructure or admin/root rights. If you don’t believe this is true, please point out where the weakness in their code is, it’s open for review and for anyone to point out its flaws.
Lastly, the FBI cannot compel anyone - individuals or companies - to work on anything without compensation. That is considered forced labor, which is highly illegal in the United States where Signal resides. The FBI attempted to force Apple to develop software to compromise the security of iOS, but they dropped the case, likely because they knew they would fail. Although they claim they found the software they needed elsewhere [0].
So the FBI can ask Signal for assistance, but that’s it. Signal must comply with the law so they always provide the info they do have - which is the data I previously pointed out - but they do not have to build any such system that would compromise the security of their service as it would fall under forced labor; i.e. developing software against their will.
100% agree with you about being unable to confirm what the server is doing, but the fact of the matter is anyone you interact with - centralized server-client or decentralized peer-to-peer - can store some metadata.
Private contact discovery is engineered in a way that you would be unable to retrieve what is being processed even if you had access to Signal’s infrastructure or admin/root rights. If you don’t believe this is true, please point out where the weakness in their code is, it’s open for review and for anyone to point out its flaws.
Lastly, the FBI cannot compel anyone - individuals or companies - to work on anything without compensation. That is considered forced labor, which is highly illegal in the United States where Signal resides. The FBI attempted to force Apple to develop software to compromise the security of iOS, but they dropped the case, likely because they knew they would fail. Although they claim they found the software they needed elsewhere [0].
So the FBI can ask Signal for assistance, but that’s it. Signal must comply with the law so they always provide the info they do have - which is the data I previously pointed out - but they do not have to build any such system that would compromise the security of their service as it would fall under forced labor; i.e. developing software against their will.
[0] https://www.beencrypted.com/news/apple-vs-fbi-events-summary/
deleted by creator