I want to add a community that is essentially the Lemmy version of an existing subreddit (r/mcmansionhell). Is this allowed?
You must log in or # to comment.
Yes, that’s perfectly ok.
deleted by creator
Heck you can even start crossposting content with credit.
I’ve seen at least six communities with the same or similar concepts/names as a subreddit, and at least a dozen posts around various communities encouraging any kind of post or engagement including new community creation. Be the content creator you want to see in the fediverse.
Hell, make a copy on every instance.
Okay, thanks everyone!
So is there a way to view this on kbin or do I always have to view it on sh.itjust.works?
you should be able to view it wherever you use lemmy. they’re all federated
https://kbin.social/m/mcmansionhell@sh.itjust.works
This should work after searching the URL straight from kbin… but searching it right now gives me a 500 Server error. Seems like it’s having technical issues.
I think It’s because someone from Kbin needs to subscribe to it first. I just did that and the link works now. Though federation doesn’t work retroactively, so the existing posts aren’t showing up.
I’ve been getting 500s all day so it’s most likely the server not being able to keep up with the Reddit migration
400s errors are server side. 500s errors are your side.
Other way around. 400s are client errors, 500s are server errors.
You can see the full list of http error codes and descriptions of what they mean here
Hah, thanks. Am a potato.
@notexecutive@sh.itjust.works
WE’RE IN BABY!!!
I turn around and some internet stranger opens up McMansionHell in a proper fresh new adorable place. Thank you.
You can also post it on- new communities ,or one of those other thats similar so more people will see it
I tried posting from Mastodon and it worked although the title didn’t come through quite right.
I saw I think <:3
If you can change the title through lemmy, to have the “CityName, StateName - Tag” format, that would be really helpful!
Awesome. I see no issue with it… only thing I’d add is that it would probably be morally encouraged, when it comes to subs with creative/non-obvious concepts to 1) allow for the mods who created the original to mod here if they want and 2) stay true to the original idea of the sub. As a homage to the mods and users who fostered the original community.
I want to do that! Should I just message them directly?
What I’ve seen some magazines do is simply have the magazine’s explanatory text say that “this is not the same team from r/whatever from reddit, if that’s you and you want to mod here just reach out” or something. Though I imagine that makes more sense if the sub stayed privated on reddit, if they’re still reddit mods and just gave into reddit pressure I’d just tell them to stay there…
There’s nothing wrong with that. Lemmy is it’s own thing, create whatever community you want based on whatever criteria you want. Just follow the rules your whatever instance you’re creating the community at.
Fuck yeah it is! Make as many subs as you want baby! This is the Wild West and we have blackjack and hookers! Make a McMansion magazine. Hell, make two!
The content does not belong to reddit but to the community so I see no reason not to copy it
…uh, which magazine contains blackjack and hookers?
I’ve seen it talked about a few times across different platforms (Hackernews) where people have pondered the idea of cloning old posts, keeping the poster name but to a non-existent account. Acting as both a way to populate a community and archive content away from Reddit’s control.
I haven’t seen any examples of this done yet, not sure if anyone has.
It would be a bit of a project, but the most time-consuming part is already done. /r/datahoarder has a backup of reddit comment/post history that goes from the beginning of reddit up to March of 2023 (text only, no media). It’s compressed down to about 2TB in size, but already in json format and anyone can download it, would just need some work to convert that to a format a fediverse instance could work with and somehow inject it into a new instance.
Do you mean they have a backup of comment and post history from /r/datahoarder or a backup of literally all reddit?
Literally all of reddit. The entire platform.
Wow. That’s really impressive. I really enjoyed that sub.
Also surprising it’s only 2TB.
It’s JSON so it’s only text, and it’s compressed, but that’s still 1 trillion characters assuming it’s UTF-16. I’ve not actually taken a look myself at the data though, I just contributed to let my PC contribute to the project.
I’ve been thinking about this, but I’ve heard the moderation is a lot of work.
I suppose yes. I basically copied a bunch of them.
Ah yes. URL-Squatters.
