I get that, if things are not changed on the Apple side, websites can’t have proper notification so you are forced to have an app but on android PWA (Progressive Web Apps - basically websites on steroids) are a real thing and you can just “install” the lemmy website of your instance and avoid any bloated app. Are you looking for an app with some feature missing from the website? Are you just unaware of the possibility of installing the website itself? I don’t want to sound rude (English isn’t my first language) but I don’t get what to me looks like an obsession to have a bloated app installed on your phone

  • Dreadino@feddit.it
    191·
    1 year ago

    I’m an Android developer, I usually spot a non native app immediately and the flaws in the ui are really annoying. Web apps are even worse.

    • Edo78@feddit.itOP
      1·
      1 year ago

      I’m a backend developer so I may be wrong but if the problems are in the UI can’t a different frontend solve the issue? I’m unable to spot the difference between sarif and sens sarif fonts so I really don’t have any reason to install an app if the website offer a usable UI

      • Dreadino@feddit.it
        1·
        1 year ago

        The problem is that a webapp will not offer a ui native to a OS. Android, iOS, web, macOS, Windows, all have different ideas about everything that’s concerning the UI and UX, from the way to go back, to the position of buttons, to the durations of animations, to the bounciness of things on the screen. Either the web developer creates 5 different ui/ux version of the same app and preys that the browser supports everything he needs, or the webapp will feel native at best on 1 OS.

        Applications also have access to APIs that a webapp can’t use, like widgets, shortcuts in various parts of the OS, deeper access to bt, contacts, cameras and a slew of other things. Even a “simple” usecase as Reddit/Lemmy could use deeper APIs than what a webapp can do.

        That said, I’m at about 60 delivered apps, at least 20 of them should have been websites.

  • shortwavesurfer@monero.town
    7·
    1 year ago

    PWAs work for sure, but you can really tell its just a full screen mobile website in a vast majority of cases. I am in no way saying PWAs are bad, but with apps that hook into APIs you have much wider latitude for how the data is presented and design choices

    • Edo78@feddit.itOP
      21·
      1 year ago

      Can’t you just write a new web frontend? without having to write an entire app?

        • Edo78@feddit.itOP
          1·
          1 year ago

          so why do people asks for mobile apps instead of alternative web frontends (besides iOS users that are locked by apple)

          • mr_washee_washee@sh.itjust.works
            2·
            1 year ago

            man mobile apps are just a needless burden to carry around. instance owners are the ones who moderate them as well, like its a one-man band. instances that arent breaking down and that get to be quickly upgraded are the fittest to survive. we dont need to accomodate ios users and we dont need apps that uploads videos in 4k quality, and ones that include the rest of the bells and wisstles. i really hope that things stay this way and i hope we stay a minority, that way our communities stay healthy and sustainable. once quantity starts to be valued more over quality thats when the ends begins and things start to get worse for everyone. i am 💯% on ur side.

  • eeltech@lemm.ee
    5·
    1 year ago

    To me, properly optimized native apps tend to be less-bloated than their web equivalents. Have you ever used “RIF is fun” for reddit? It is amazing, lots of tiny UI optimizations make it a pleasure to consume content much faster than scrolling up and down reddit’s UI for both links and comments

      • eeltech@lemm.ee
        2·
        1 year ago

        Are you going to ignore the rest of what I wrote? lol

        Have you ever used “RIF is fun” for reddit? It is amazing, lots of tiny UI optimizations make it a pleasure to consume content much faster than scrolling up and down reddit’s UI for both links and comments

        The app just feels better/faster. Think of this way: a webapp = browser + pwa. You have all of the resource requirements of the browser itself, plus whatever it needs to render the html/css of the webapp running on top of that. many webapps are just written so poorly (like the new reddit page) that the browser struggles to do simple things like smooth scrolling). Plus being native means there is better support for things like save/print dialogs, themes/dark mode, helper apps/intents, etc)

        If none of this matters to you and a webapp feels ok to you, that’s great! use what you want! I’m happy for you

        But you came in here asking why people prefer native apps and we gave you an answer, you don’t have to be antagonistic

        • Edo78@feddit.itOP
          11·
          1 year ago

          first things first … English isn’t my first language and I’m sorry if I sounded antagonistic. I’m a bit frustrated because, a lot of users doesn’t even know about PWA and they asks for the development of mobile apps when their needs can be fulfilled with a PWA

          I don’t recall using RIF for reddit, I remember trying a lot of app and feel like I was let down by them so I switch to the browser. It did what I need, I didn’t even feel it lagging while scrolling. Ok, PWA doesn’t have access to some native API (and I’m not even sure if apple finally gave up and let its users have browser push notifications) but for some usecases this isn’t a problem …

  • sideone@lemmy.world
    3·
    1 year ago

    Are you just unaware of the possibility of installing the website itself?

    I haven’t heard about this, and I suspect that plenty of people are in the same situation. How do you install a website?

    • Edo78@feddit.itOP
      2·
      1 year ago

      I’m using Lemmy from the mobile website while Jerboa still doesn’t let me do some things (at least in the weekend, don’t know if it’s updated) and it almost 70 times bigger than the PWA

  • IuseArchbtw@feddit.de
    1·
    1 year ago

    I use Jerboa as an app forLemmzy and it doesn’t really feel bloated. I am also a big fan of Infinity for reddit.

    • Edo78@feddit.itOP
      2·
      1 year ago

      is it some kind of proxy that translate from a format to another to help moving the reddit apps to talk with lemmy? My question remain … why an app instead of a website?

      • Communist@beehaw.org
        4·
        1 year ago

        Because sync for reddit is absolutely better than the lemmy website in just about every feasible way.

        • Edo78@feddit.itOP
          1·
          1 year ago

          never find an app I liked for reddit … my question still remain shouldn’t be faster to write a web frontend similar to an app instead of writing a proxy just to keep using an app that waste way more space on the device?

          • Communist@beehaw.org
            1·
            1 year ago

            The proxy is hosted on the lemmy instance, it allows the reddit apps to interface with lemmy, it won’t take up more space on the device than the app itself.

            One of the last things i’m worried about on my phone is the amount of space I have, i’d rather have a fluid, native interface.

            • Edo78@feddit.itOP
              1·
              1 year ago

              I was talking about the space of the app not the proxy. Sorry but I still don’t get your point … don’t you think that a light PWA can be fluider and faster than an app? It’s surely lighter so it’s an objective point in its favour

  • ebike_enjoyer@beehaw.org
    1·
    1 year ago

    A lot of the people coming in right now are specifically protesting Reddit due to the shut down of their preferred third party apps, especially Apollo, an iOS exclusive. Android has Jerboa and PWAs, but on iOS we just have the site (and mlem, but it’s very early days there). I think that if/when old Reddit gets shut down, the resulting exodus from that will not care as much about app access, as they were using the web previously.