I actually want to see reddit kill 3rd party apps, this will provide a huge opportunity to Lemmy, and show how much power these Reddit Admins hold.
Never interrupt your enemy when he is making a mistake.
—Shang Tsung
Reddit is determined to “go commercial”. It’ll be successful at first because there’s a wealth of good data in Reddit. However, those who contribute rather than just consume will drift away. The content becomes stale (who wants recommendations for great Bluetooth headsets from 2015?).
Cory Doctorow wrote an excellent article on how TikTok, Facebook, Amazon and more have become worse, and why. It was written in January before Reddit’s API announcement, but it applies to Reddit every bit as much as the others. It’s worth a read: Tiktok’s enshittification
That article is fantastic, read it when it was first posted and just read it again now. His closing lines hit home:
“…policymakers should focus on freedom of exit – the right to leave a sinking platform while continuing to stay connected to the communities that you left behind, enjoying the media and apps you bought, and preserving the data you created…”
“The Netheads were right: technological self-determination is at odds with the natural imperatives of tech businesses. They make more money when they take away our freedom – our freedom to speak, to leave, to connect.”
Holy enshittification batman. That’s an enlightening read. Thank you.
That article was absolutely brutal. This is what happens when you put all of your eggs in one basket. Incidentally, many youtubers have been suffering from the phenomenon too. When a company grows big enough, this sort of thing seems to happen every time.
Let them at this point. I’m all for moving to the open source alternative here
So much more longterm possibilities
Reddit has been going downhill for ages. They stopped listening to the users, its customers, years ago. They started becoming more ‘Social’ as they put it. Adding chat features, and other useless features. All the time ignoring important things like stopping spam, decent moderation tools, blocking people, etc… I have been using Old.Reddit with Reddit Enhancement Suite for years to make the site usable. I will miss Reddit, but I have been missing it for quite some time.
As for people who put effort into apps, subreddits, etc… Yes, it’s a shame, but the internet evolves and moves on. Harsh but true. Hopefully, these people will see a future elsewhere. Because a good portion of those people are talented. Maybe one of them can produce apps for Kbin.social? Who knows what they will find to put their energy into, maybe one such person leaving Reddit will create a new social media site we all flock too?
I will be watching to see what happens. Yes I support those fighting to keep 3rd party access, specially as it means some with certain needs (Like the blind) will have no access at all to Reddit. I also think this shake-up is needed. I will be using the Fediverse.
I wrote this on another instance but will paste it here as adds to your first paragraph
and the original founders would have never allowed Reddit to get to this point.
Unfortunately, at least one of the original founders has allowed, quite possibly even driven this policy. Steve Huffman is still very much at the helm and what he has exposed of himself in interviews, he doesn’t sound like a very nice person (re: post apocalypse, he sees himself being on top and having slaves)
It’s great that subs and users are organising to fight this but maybe Reddit should be allowed to carry out this change and metaphorically shoot itself in the face? This is just the latest in a long horrifying series of policies that the admins have pushed through, actions they have failed to take, or when they finally did, it was long after the horse had bolted.
Remember the jailbait (and worse) subs that they allowed for so long (and were rumoured to have participated in) and when they finally did something after Anderson Cooper shone a light under that dark, seedy rock, they picked their sacrificial lamb and blamed it all on him? Remember the secret santa parallel site someone set up that Reddit then forcibly absorbed and let wilt? Remember how they dealt with Victoria who arranged all the celebrity IAMA’s? Remember how they brought in Ellen Pao (with her own set of issues) to deal with horrific amount of far right and misogynist subs that were actively calling for peoples and groups deaths, and then threw her under the bus once they got what they needed? Remember how they were banning people and deleting posts when it was revealed that 5 mod accounts were basically controlling the top 100 subs? Remember how they appointed to the admins a person who was found to be grooming teens and was supportive of their father who was convicted of serious sexual assault of a child?
The list is never-ending…
The sad fact of the matter is that centralised social medias one driving factor is money. They acquire that via data points collection from engagement. They dont care what kind of engagement as long as theres plenty of it and hateful content drives engagement.
There is no sense of community among the admins and execs of Reddit. It is entirely from the users.
The original founders allowed this to happen, if they didn’t drive this. Many similar times previously, and undoubtedly, many more times to come.
Maybe Reddit, just like every other centralised, corporate owned social media sites time is over?
I just dont believe its something worth fighting for, despite how commendable the actions of all those subs is.
@Warped @bitman09 right there with you.
I really started to notice it when they just ignored for months the hate subreddit theDonald, right before the 2016 election.
It was a year after they started banning subreddits for hate speech, but not this one. Not after the election was done and dealt with, after thousands of reports to admins, news articles, printscreens of hate speech, because money…Old.Reddit with Reddit Enhancement Suite for years to make the site usable
Hello, dear friend 🤝
I’m still there for the obscure subreddits and for users that are there not because of ‘engagement’ but for the love of it.
Yeah with old.reddit and the usability of RES going away my desire to use the site will completely evaporate. Agreed on that I mostly use it for niche interest and specific game subreddits.
Though it sounds like RES is optimistic that they won’t be affected too badly: https://old.reddit.com/r/RESAnnouncements/comments/141hyv3/announcement_res_reddits_upcoming_api_changes/
For their own sake, hope they don’t kill old.reddit.
Never used their official app but only used one 3rd party app, Bacon Reader. I’m not one who likes staring and posting/commenting from my mobile so didn’t use that for long.
Also remember that reddit loves to choose what goes on front page, have the worst mods ever and shadow banning. Those things should not be tolerated. I don’t mind if reddit disappear, it is pretty toxic.
The worst mods can happen anywhere.
On Reddit specifically, these mods of large subreddits, for example Gallowboob, are appointed by Reddit staff. These appointed mods run hundreds of large subreddits per account and Reddit has quietly banned community moderators who opposed the appointed mods. So it’s not like a bad admin of a Lemmy instance as a bad Lemmy admin is simply a random person who decided to run a website. The power-tripping mods on Reddit are a deliberate decision by Reddit.
I didn’t know they were appointed by Reddit but i guess that makes sense for a centralised service.
Seems a lot of the political subreddits are giant echo chambers filled with groupthink.
Yeah, I’m pretty sure that’s by design. It’s powerful tool for pushing an agenda. Moderation only makes it more powerful.
I want to see Reddit fail tbh. It was great at one point, but it won’t be great again. It’s time for the platform to shoot itself in the foot to allow better platforms such as Lemmy to grow.
The fact that they can kill third party apps is exactly why we need something else.
Let it burn I say
Nah let reddit decay into FB 2.0
I’d say let that ship sink. We’ve got alternatives. Even if we miss the communities and knowledge etc.
Not sure what to prefer… open reddit API or reddit descending and people switching to open alternatives… It seems like there is a huge mods issue on reddit as well, which won’t be solved any time soon.
I see a lot of people saying let this happen. I acknowledge that reddit has also sort of lost their point but a lot of people have put countless hours into building stuff both on communities and as devs building apps like redreader and rif. I don’t want to see all of those people basically lose all their effort and work because a company decided to make money.
Thats a sunk cost fallacy though.
Reddit isnt going to get better and the admins/exec are just going to keep pushing policies like this because their primary motivation is to make money and they desperately want to hold a Reddit IPO.
The best options is for all those subs to export as much as they can to create a read only archive then head elsewhere where they control their own data.
Sure, as it’s evident from us interacting here I’ve been trying to move on the alternatives, though nothing has sprung upto replace niche subreddits that I used to browse.
Ultimately my point was not that what reddit was doing was right. It was that it is easy to take joy in a company that has let greed take over try to fail but in doing so don’t forget to have some empathy for countless volunteers who put in time and effort to build something worthwhile. It’s their stuff that’s being burnt too.
I take no pleasure in what the impact is going to be with numerous communities but I will admit that I’m gleefully rubbing my hands watching the admins make a complete pigs ear of yet another situation.
My comment was more about just how many times will people get shitted on by the admins (Ive commented elsewhere just some of the awful and horrific situations they have caused or failed to act upon) before they realise that the admins are going to repeatedly carry out the same kind of behaviours and it is not the best place for them.
Its long overdue time to gather what they can carry and abandon ship.
I can’t imagine what a loss it will be if many of the niche communities die on reddit and aren’t reborn on other platforms. Right now it looks like some of my favourite ones are going that way.
Imho they should start migrating. Maybe not now or immediately, but gradually. Reddit has shown its hand. I don’t think they’ll go back to their roots in the foreseeable future.
Definitely agree. I am using both now and I hope as more communities make their way here I can reduce how much I use reddit because it’s full of rage bait for me.
I’m just not wanting to wish it go dead and have a lot of people lose access to something they really cared about.
Demonstrated by the other post I made in this thread, Reddit has been showing its hand for a very long time but the analogy of frogs in pans of boiling water comes to mind with the user base.
Reddit will never go back to its roots of being 3 guys at college with an idea for a site. It will always be the money craving corporate beast its evolved into.
Once they decided to go public, it was all over. There was literally no saving it.
The risk of this happening is part of the deal when you play inside someone else’s walled garden. The same applies to devs of 3rd party apps.
It wasn’t a walled garden for a long time. There was a time when reddit codebase was opensource. So it isn’t fair to say these people should be blamed for using someone else’s walled garden.
I think Reddit is going to do what they’re going to do. I’ll be here instead.
deleted by creator
