In 2016, we started running the messenger review series on decentralize.today since we anticipated how significant they would become in the mix of communication options and the impact on privacy.

  • @davidsong
    link
    8
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    I ran it for a bit a few years ago when I had very bad internet on holiday - I could never get it working. It hogged all my battery for ages and couldn’t send a message to my gf who was right next to me.

    IMO the way for mesh messaging tech to gain a foothold is by being useful when there’s a bunch of people in a location where there’s no internet, so they should be targeted at those people first:

    • Holiday destinations where people are charged for WiFi and the mobile network is either under heavy pressure or not available (campsites, cruise ships, holidays where roaming charges hurt)
    • Hiking, where people have intermittent internet but other people are sometimes in range for relaying messages
    • Music festivals, where huge numbers of people gathered in one place overload the network.
    • Nightclubs and warehouse parties where you’re in a metal box with no signal unless you go for a smoke
    • A device that doesn’t have a network subscription, like tablets, but wants to get messages while away from WiFi networks

    Then build a public mesh that has utility, not this crazy one-hop fundamentalism but something that actually works.

    • Graveyard Leprechaun
      link
      52 years ago

      Your criticism is based upon an experience from ‘a few years ago’. Maybe give the latest build a try.

    • seahorse [Ohio]
      link
      fedilink
      22 years ago

      I tested it out a few months ago on Android and it worked really well. Tested it out with bluetooth as well as with an internet connection.