• 0 Posts
  • 11 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: March 24th, 2022

help-circle



  • The thing is , this war was already continuing for 8 years and the Russian side tried to make peace with Ukraine this whole time. I don’t think that Russia is doing it out of some noble intentions , but it doesn’t really add up with “they just went there for oil” narrative. More so , it was the Ukrainian side which showed it’s unwillingness for peace , violating Minsk agreements by continuously bombing Donbass regions.




  • I just looked a little into it and basically he said: “the rate of natural increase was x , but it should’ve been y instead!” And that’s how he got this 110 million number. Absolutely amazing. Yep , see no problem with that. Next , he started to count people , who died from WWII and got 44 million deaths and blamed “Stalin’s tactics” (whatever that means) for such high casualties. Doing some complex scientific research (110 - 44 = 66) he concluded that 66 million or 60% of total deaths were done in non-war time…

    And then he refused to elaborate further.




  • Neon__volktoCommunism@lemmygrad.mlRussia is Marching Towards Socialism
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    11
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    3 years ago

    Jesse , what the fuck are you talking about?

    OK , I relatively agree with the first paragraph , except Medvedev is pretty much can be seen as a Putin’s puppet and a way for Putin to abuse 2-term election limit (for those who don’t know , in Russia you only can’t be elected more than 2 times IN A ROW , which basically means nothing stops you from becoming a president again after there was a diffirent president elected before you)

    Having NEP and Gosplan doesn’t imply that he actually believes in ideals of communism. Even South Korea used 5-year plans to their advantage and yet it didn’t move closer to communism by even an inch. It might instead be done for purely pragmatic reasons , such as reduction of significant oligarchic influence or perhaps him trying to replicate China’s success (we may never know).

    The thing which you call “a praise of Communist figures” isn’t actually a praise , but might be quite the opposite. He compares communism to religion and Lenin’s mausoleum to relics of saints. Considering that Putin is a religious conservative it may be not a necessarily negative remark , but his intention doesn’t really matter , as no principled communist would compare communism with religion in the first place. May I also remind you , that he recently criticised and blamed Lenin for existence of Ukrainian state.

    Zyuganov has a bad reputation among russian communists. It’s believed that he’s just a controlled opposition and judging by his party’s manifesto , CPRF is just a succdem party with Soviet Aesthetics.

    By far , even his critique of capitalism doesn’t seem to come from socialist perspective , either. He believes in his own thing , which he himself calls “a reasonable conservatism”.

    Now , about him supposedly “declaring oligarchs as traitors” , I understand Russian and there was no ‘oligarchs’ mentioned in his speech in the video. It looks like he bashes pro-western liberals more than anything.

    At his early years he actually wanted to join NATO and the reason he now opposes them because NATO rejected him , not the other way around.

    But ngl , it would be hilarious if he really was one of those “conservative socialist” types , but I doubt it.