• wiki_me
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    4 years ago

    he is basing his conclusions based on the-federation.info, Which does not report accurately the number of active users, some of the most popular projects (in term of number of instances as you can see on the front page), don’t report the number of active users, while diaspora which does report active users seem to be in decline .

    The number of instances increased a lot (from 5600 to 7300). Asking that projects such as peertube and pleroma will report active users will help us get a more accurate picture. also having information about the number of instances and active users every year so we could see if there is growth every year could also help.

    • Niquarl
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      4 years ago

      Perhaps the best indicator of the ‘health’ and growth of the fediverse is the number of instances. I also wonder how many people have created accounts of ‘big’ instances and then move to smaller, newer instances.

      • wiki_me
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        4 years ago

        I don’t think so, if you would look at hubzilla for example you would see that the number of instances grew smaller yet the number of active users grew significantly. I think that for most people when it comes to self hosting “the juice isn’t worth the squeeze” and they are better of in some instance of some dedicated nonprofit like feneas or disroot.

        • Niquarl
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          4 years ago

          As I am on the original mastodon.social instance and have to no plan to change (at least for the time being) I can understand that. Perhaps a better way then would be to kind of see how many instances are on the network because that definetely is good for the fediverse and then count the users of the top 10 largest instances. After all, those top 10 instances have quite a lot of users already to be honest. I only know one other person that is on the fediverse and yet a use it weekly, because it has an appeal to me in a way that Diaspora* for example never had. I guess I like microblogging and what the people I follow microblog about. I think it’s safe to say that Mastodon has been a success, wether that success will ultimately still be there in 10 years is very hard to know. It needs to bring more people in that know eachother in real life I think, or perhaps via the other platforms like Pixelfed for example is better suited for ‘IRL’ people. After all, how many friends that know eachother off the internet interact on Twitter ?