• @TheAnonymouseJoker
    link
    -42 years ago

    DeHuMaNiZinG nAziS iS BaD

    southerntofu’s past few days of posting amidst the Russia-Ukraine conflict is very revealing of the immense NATO apologia, and this user is purely attempting to gaslight Lemmy now. He already called me a Russian Empire puppet.

    • @southerntofu
      link
      42 years ago

      DeHuMaNiZinG nAziS iS BaD

      I’m not saying nazis should be treated gently. I appreciate the importance and cost of struggles, and do believe in the therapeutic values of a punch in a nazi’s faith (realizing how much people hate your nazi ideology may help you get connected to reality). But, this being said, i am strongly against dehumanizing nazis as it’s not helping them become anything else, and it’s not helping us develop an actual opposition to nazism as an ideology/praxis.

      Demonization/dehumanization is what the liberal western establishment has been doing to the fascists ever since WWII and where has it lead us? It leads to a superficial (mis)understanding of nazism/fascism where it’s not evident why so many millions of people have suddenly become crazy and started slaughtering their neighbors. It does not account for racist propaganda and the “manufacture of consent”, authoritarian tendencies and centralized State apparatus, ordinary political repression (“first they came for…”).

      In the aftermath of WWII, dehumanization is the process that enabled to chop a few heads (Nuremberg trials) and then consider the matter resolved, without any concern for:

      • putting on trial the industrials who supported Hitler (the trial was supposed to happen but never took place, as outlined in the Fascism Inc. documentary)
      • the long history of racial hierarchies and cultural supremacy in Europe long before the nazis rose to power, and long after they were defeated: Hitler did not invent concentration camps, political repression or racial hierarchies, and he’s certainly not the last to have done that in Europe

      On a timeline that’s closer to me as a live being, demonizing the Front National here in France has not helped to defeat it. Why? Because while the Front National has (over decades) become slightly more moderate in its discourse, the entire political apparatus from left (PCF) to right (UMP/LR) has shifted to a profoundly racist and securitarian agenda which was justified (in their claims) by the idea that if “immigration” and “security” themes are the monopoly of the Front National, then surely the Front National will rise to power. So by both dehumanizing fascists while at the same time (re)building their own brand of french fascism, they have in essence bolstered fascism and racist discourse in a way that most people (myself included) twenty years ago would have not thought possible.

      Fascism, like any structure of oppression, has many facets, some of which traverse all of us. Fascism is a direct by-product and the logical conclusion of capitalism. Pointing the finger at specific manifestations of fascism without looking at the whole picture is feel-goodism to sleep at night, but fails to address the power structures and political/economic incentives driving the rise of fascist discourse in all veins of society.

      Fuck fascism. Fuck France. Fuck NATO. Vive la Commune!

      • @TheAnonymouseJoker
        link
        -42 years ago

        Demonization/dehumanization is what the liberal western establishment has been doing to the fascists ever since WWII and where has it lead us?

        Oh, and what is then exactly the Cold War and McCarthyism? What is Russophobia and Sinophobia? What is the hatred for black/brown/non-Caucasian immigrants in white countries?

        And what is NATO’s Chief being the same as Hitler’s army chief? Or Werner von Braun being head of NASA? Or Kurt Waldheim being the UN Secretary General? Or Walter Hallstein being Head of EU Commission?

        Writing long “both sides bad” paragraphs is not going to let you get away with this. Go balance NATO media if you are so adamant, because that is the dominant tool for actual colonialists. Calling Russia empire/colonialist/imperialist is pure white lies and an attempt to whitewash Anglo-Saxon doings by omission of argument.

        • @southerntofu
          link
          62 years ago

          Oh, and what is then exactly the Cold War and McCarthyism? What is Russophobia and Sinophobia? What is the hatred for black/brown/non-Caucasian immigrants in white countries?

          It’s precisely the result of demonizing nazism without analyzing/deconstructing its narratives and modes of operation. This is why to this day in Europe many people who would spit on a swastika can hold proto-nazi discourse without even realizing it. Antifascism is not a moral position, it’s a struggle for emancipation. Only the liberals play the moralizing game because it makes them feel good about themselves while discounting their own mechanisms of oppression.

          Calling Russia empire/colonialist/imperialist is (…) an attempt to whitewash Anglo-Saxon doings by omission of argument

          Feel free to check out my post history. I don’t exactly hide my hatred for western empires either. On the other hand, you seem very misinformed about the imperialist history of Russia (both monarchist and bolshevik). I strongly recommend you do some reading on racism and cultural supremacy in ex-USSR territories.

          • @TheAnonymouseJoker
            link
            -1
            edit-2
            2 years ago

            I know about Duginism and Russian traditionalism, but I also know about NATO and Anglo-Saxon imperialist history, which you try to whitewash, from a 10 minute analysis of your comments.

            You have repeatedly made claims of

            • “both are imperialist assholes”
            • “people who are no fools of the Russian/NATO propaganda”
            • “you support Russian fascism”
            • “you are a puppet of the Russian empire”
            • “carefully ignore that the Russian army is also full of nazis”
            • “anti-imperialist thinkers/fighters who oppose NATO are also opposing Putin’s imperialism on Ukraine”
            • “while many national outlet are spewing NATO propaganda, others are spewing Kremlin propaganda”
            • “geopolitical concerns between the two big empires (Russia and NATO)”
            • “Putin and NATO are two sides of the same colonialist garbage”

            and so on. This is all from your comment history of the past 2 days.

            I recommend you stop being morally corrupt and play the grifty both sides trope. If you have any semblance of morality left over to self critique, go try commenting something highly critical of NATO and Ukraine’s Nazi military on Twitter and watch what happens to your tweet and account. Try it out now, and see for yourself.