- cross-posted to:
- piracy@lemmy.dbzer0.com
- i2p
- cross-posted to:
- piracy@lemmy.dbzer0.com
- i2p
Just a PSA that I2P exists if you want to try out anonymous torrenting. Head over to I2P for questions on how to set it up.
I won’t answer questions that could get me into legal trouble, but I’d be happy to help with more generic I2P things.
Unfortunately the elephant in the room with I2P for torrenting is speed, given its routing nature. I haven’t tried it myself, but I’ve seen it discussed in the past and how people were complaining about dial-up speeds. In your experience, what have your speeds been like? What’s your average download speed? I’m guessing lower than 100kbps?
If it’s that slow, do you think it’s a problem of not enough peers… or of the routing protocol that needs to happen for privacy?
Speed is an issue. That’s the trade-off you do for security. However the speeds have improved over the last couple of releases, but no where near what you get from “normal” torrenting.
Can’t say what my average speed is because I don’t know, but I believe it’s higher.
Just to update you on the speed issue. I’m trying out a small swarm legal download at the moment, less than 10 peers and I’m at +300kBps, which admittedly is shit compared to what you can get from normal torrents. I have seen download speeds in the MBps, but that’s rare.
I’d guess normal speeds are 1 - 500kBps.
It’s worth pointing out that depending on the type of content you’re downloading +300kBps is pretty darn good. For ebooks, audiobooks, songs, and some isos those speeds are plenty. It’d be pretty interesting if a niche around those kind of contents developed for I2P torrenting.
I know about I2P for some time now and I really like the pitch, but I never got around of actually trying it sadly.
Perhaps today is the day?
Off-topic question: what does “PSA” stand for?
“Public Service Announcement”, sorry, I thought that was a common shorthand.
Thanks! It kind of is, I saw it several times the last few days (never noticed before). It’s kinda variant of FYI I guess?
Public Service Announcement
Is torrenting actually allowed/encouraged on i2p or is it something possible but frowned on by the community? How’s torrenting speed compared to clearnet torrenting or socks5/vpn torrenting?
It’s designed for torrenting primarily
What makes I2P anonymous?
Also how is it different from normal torrenting?
What makes it different is that I2P uses something called garlic routing to anonymize you and everyone participating in the swarm. So nobody can tell what you’re downloading, except those in the same swarm, but they can’t tell who you are because your id in the swarm isn’t connected to your IP-address.
Other than that it’s pretty much normal torrenting. Many clients such as BiglyBT already support I2P.
deleted by creator
how to enable this I2P in qbittorrent? Or if its not possible what torrent client do you recommend for Linux?
I don’t use qbittorent I’m afraid, but someone created a tutorial for it if you know how to download from a torrent hash it’s here: Torrent hash = 3F1D51095F9B116739172C1BCED149ACF2B10692
If not then there’s a built in torrent client called I2PSnark in the java version. It’s rather basic but it’ll get the job done.
do i need to have I2P installed on my system to work with I2PSnark?
Yes, but the installation is pretty straightforward.
but it’s working only on applications that i need, right(torrent client for example)?
Not sure I understood the question.
undefined> I2PSnark
Is it working system-wide, like openvpn?
No, not system wide by default. Change your browser proxy to localhost:4444 and you should be able to reach i2p-sites like http://planet.i2p or the bittorrent tracker (linked in the I2P sub). Changing that will make use of the outproxies so it’ll kind of work like TOR.
Thank you very much i’ll try this out
AFAIK, the issue with i2p is what trackers one can hook to, right? I believe only special trackers supporting i2p, and with limited content are out there. Has that changed?
To me, that’s even more important than speed.