That’s sort of off topic though. Sure there were anarchists in Ukraine during the civil war putting their own plans into action, but by 1921, these factions did not exist anymore, and the soviet policy was then put into place.
What I meant by collectivization here was the specific policy enacted in 1929 while Stalin was leader, because that’s the topic of discussion.
Soviets were the foundation of the revolution in 1917, long before Lenin and his friends stole it. And yes, after Lenin and Trotsky shot all the revolutionaries (anarchists and libertarian communists), you can say with confidence they “did not exist anymore”.
What I meant by collectivization here was the specific policy enacted in 1929
That’s sort of off topic though. Sure there were anarchists in Ukraine during the civil war putting their own plans into action, but by 1921, these factions did not exist anymore, and the soviet policy was then put into place.
What I meant by collectivization here was the specific policy enacted in 1929 while Stalin was leader, because that’s the topic of discussion.
Soviets were the foundation of the revolution in 1917, long before Lenin and his friends stole it. And yes, after Lenin and Trotsky shot all the revolutionaries (anarchists and libertarian communists), you can say with confidence they “did not exist anymore”.
Thanks for clarifying.