A chairdre! This is a continuation of our discussion from the previous post: https://lemmygrad.ml/post/395378

Firstly, the link to the essay collection in question: https://transreads.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/2021-07-15_60f0b3d5edcb7_jules-joanne-gleeson-transgender-marxism-1.pdf

Today, I’ll be reading the first essay in the collection, Social Reproduction and Social Cognition: Theorizing (Trans)gender Identity Development in Community Context - Noah Zazanis

Noah Zazanis is a Marxist feminist, epidemiological researcher, and unrepentant transsexual. He lives in Queens and writes and organizes when he can.

I’ll pull some quotes and make some notes.

I hope that this will spark a discussion, or at the very least someone will have a chance to learn a little something <3

Edit 1: The discussion continues here with the second essay by Michelle O’Brien here - https://lemmygrad.ml/post/397671

  • Seanchaí (she/her)OPM
    link
    fedilink
    52 years ago

    “For working-class trans people of colour, however, community identity development is most often necessarily inextricable from the reproduction of everyday life. Largely without the access to funding and medicalised legitimacy held by white-led NGOs, trans people of colour (particularly Black and Brown trans women) have developed extensive grassroots mutual aid networks and chosen familial structures”

    While the self-efficacy of interaction with other trans people is often essential to the social reproduction of trans identities, this is leveraged by gender criticals as proof of “social contagion.” That people who had otherwise internalized cisgender identity roles would remain cisgender if they hadn’t been “turned” by other trans people.]

    This has led to claims of “Rapid Onset Gender Dysphoria.”

    However, if you consider the overwhelming amount of vectors for reproducing cisgenderism in children, and the acceptance of children who take on cisgender identity roles as authentic regardless of their age, this claim rings obviously false. The reproduction of cisgenderism is done through violence. The violence of the state, criminalizing trans women of colour, the violence of parents, punishing their children for deviation from cisgender identity norms, the violence of the medical establishment, reducing gender identity to a function of genitalia.

    • Seanchaí (she/her)OPM
      link
      fedilink
      52 years ago

      Alright, this was a pretty good essay. Gonna take a break before tucking into the next one. Thank you for joining me, if you have <3

      I’ll leave off with this final quote:

      “Trans people are not distinguished by our victimhood. It is in cases of cisgender identification that this coercion has been most effective.”