On hexbear people rarely offer substantive rebuttals to bad points. They use inline image memes/gifs and move on. Which doesn’t actually debunk the point and might leave some lurker thinking “huh they have a good point, people don’t like it but they won’t say why so they must have no rebuttals”. And that doesn’t create a good culture. That’s a discord culture of memeing and that becomes expected. It doesn’t show dissent, it distorts views. Because you have like 8 reactionaries, liberals, ultras, or whatever upvoting their point, then a bunch of people, maybe 6 posting reaction memes in the comments that disagree but that 8 number next to it looks a lot more approving and impactful than those reaction comments downthread.
Really bad illustration for your point but an excellent one for mine which is while people claim and hope this will happen. Guess what? The people who have the knowledge and time to do replies get burned out. There are more bad faith people out there with money, time, etc than there are communists who have the time to bat down every single new reincarnation of propaganda, a lie, ultra behavior, etc.
This is why a lot of new learner spaces are heavily moderated. Because bad faith actors come in, use certain tactics and aim to burden, overwhelm, and burn out the regular users so they don’t have a chance to interact with genuine good faith new learners.
On hexbear people rarely offer substantive rebuttals to bad points. They use inline image memes/gifs and move on. Which doesn’t actually debunk the point and might leave some lurker thinking “huh they have a good point, people don’t like it but they won’t say why so they must have no rebuttals”. And that doesn’t create a good culture. That’s a discord culture of memeing and that becomes expected. It doesn’t show dissent, it distorts views. Because you have like 8 reactionaries, liberals, ultras, or whatever upvoting their point, then a bunch of people, maybe 6 posting reaction memes in the comments that disagree but that 8 number next to it looks a lot more approving and impactful than those reaction comments downthread.
Really bad illustration for your point but an excellent one for mine which is while people claim and hope this will happen. Guess what? The people who have the knowledge and time to do replies get burned out. There are more bad faith people out there with money, time, etc than there are communists who have the time to bat down every single new reincarnation of propaganda, a lie, ultra behavior, etc.
This is why a lot of new learner spaces are heavily moderated. Because bad faith actors come in, use certain tactics and aim to burden, overwhelm, and burn out the regular users so they don’t have a chance to interact with genuine good faith new learners.