Someone lies to you a dozen times in the same way. Then they come up to you again with the same story and say they’re telling the truth. No matter what you think the merits of their story are this time around, does it make sense to believe them?
this is not some fucking made up weapons in Iraq scenario.
Are you absolutely sure about that? Would you have been against the Iraq war before it happened as well?
Look, I get it. I was in your shoes once. Ten years ago I would have figured that this a clear cut good vs. evil scenario with good guys fighting bad guys. One side is Good because they uphold Democracy, Freedom, Human Rights etc. and the other side is Bad because they are against that. There we go, fully summarized, easy to digest and wrap your head around. This kind of world view is rather easy to hold, because you don’t ever really have to think about why things happen. Things just kind of happen because the bad guys did something bad, because they are evil. They have red light sabers, they’re voldemort, they use forbidden magic. China is bad because Xi and his party are evil. Same with Putin.
But what exactly do we mean when we say “democracy, freedom, and human rights”? If you look past all the buzzwords they are rather vague, utopian concepts that very few, if any, countries can honestly say they uphold. Take my own country, Finland, for example. Widely considered a democratic and free country with a solid human rights record. But is it, really? I wouldn’t say our treatment of the Sami was particularly considerate of their human rights. Spousal abuse and alcoholism are more or less our national pastime, and let’s not even mention the suicide rates. Year after year more and more of public utilities get privatized and sold of to the highest bidder, to line the pockets of some fat cat executive, because of “the economy”. We try, successfully too, to uphold the facade of being a happy and progressive country, but man, things could be a lot better. But hey, at least we get to vote every few years, which might make us feel a little better but ultimately not really change anything. But aside from that, how free are we really when everything costs money and keeps getting more expensive? How does the threat of starvation and homelessness (yes, it’s a thing here too) unless you sacrifice most of your waking time to working comply with basic human rights? I would say it doesn’t. The “national debt” or whatever the hell the economists blame don’t mean a single fucking thing to me, the ordinary citizen. The national debt could be 0 tomorrow, and my life would not improve in the slightest. My observation of the material reality I exist in is that shit is fucked. I base this opinion on the world around me, the things I see and hear, and the people I talk to. Material things and observations, as opposed to statistics and news articles and feelgood stories and buzzwords. A Chinese or Ugandan or American citizen will hold opinions based on their observations, and arrive at a different conclusion. Putin and his lackeys, too, looked at the material reality and arrived at the conclusion that Russia must invade. Simply “being evil” is not a material, objective, quantifiable thing. NATO encroaching on the border of Russia, however, is a very material threat to the Russians, whether we think it’s good or bad or justified or not. A threat to their democracy, freedom, and human rights, or whatever buzzwords they use there, you might say.
Anyway it’s really fucking hard to deal with questioning your entire world view. I would know, because I had to go through it, and I really, really, REALLY wanted to stay in the comfy warm hot tub of my previous ideology where everything was easy to explain. But I couldn’t, because once I started asking “why?”, the ideology eventually didn’t hold up any more. Try it. “Yes, but why?” “Because X Y Z.” “Okay, but why? Why X? Where did it come from?”. Go on, ask.
You might not bother to read all this, but that’s fine. I’m kind of posting it for myself anyway.
It’s a simple question:
Someone lies to you a dozen times in the same way. Then they come up to you again with the same story and say they’re telling the truth. No matter what you think the merits of their story are this time around, does it make sense to believe them?
what does that have anything to do with the Ukraine war?
Russia did invade Ukraine, twice, this is not some fucking made up weapons in Iraq scenario.
Are you absolutely sure about that? Would you have been against the Iraq war before it happened as well?
Look, I get it. I was in your shoes once. Ten years ago I would have figured that this a clear cut good vs. evil scenario with good guys fighting bad guys. One side is Good because they uphold Democracy, Freedom, Human Rights etc. and the other side is Bad because they are against that. There we go, fully summarized, easy to digest and wrap your head around. This kind of world view is rather easy to hold, because you don’t ever really have to think about why things happen. Things just kind of happen because the bad guys did something bad, because they are evil. They have red light sabers, they’re voldemort, they use forbidden magic. China is bad because Xi and his party are evil. Same with Putin.
But what exactly do we mean when we say “democracy, freedom, and human rights”? If you look past all the buzzwords they are rather vague, utopian concepts that very few, if any, countries can honestly say they uphold. Take my own country, Finland, for example. Widely considered a democratic and free country with a solid human rights record. But is it, really? I wouldn’t say our treatment of the Sami was particularly considerate of their human rights. Spousal abuse and alcoholism are more or less our national pastime, and let’s not even mention the suicide rates. Year after year more and more of public utilities get privatized and sold of to the highest bidder, to line the pockets of some fat cat executive, because of “the economy”. We try, successfully too, to uphold the facade of being a happy and progressive country, but man, things could be a lot better. But hey, at least we get to vote every few years, which might make us feel a little better but ultimately not really change anything. But aside from that, how free are we really when everything costs money and keeps getting more expensive? How does the threat of starvation and homelessness (yes, it’s a thing here too) unless you sacrifice most of your waking time to working comply with basic human rights? I would say it doesn’t. The “national debt” or whatever the hell the economists blame don’t mean a single fucking thing to me, the ordinary citizen. The national debt could be 0 tomorrow, and my life would not improve in the slightest. My observation of the material reality I exist in is that shit is fucked. I base this opinion on the world around me, the things I see and hear, and the people I talk to. Material things and observations, as opposed to statistics and news articles and feelgood stories and buzzwords. A Chinese or Ugandan or American citizen will hold opinions based on their observations, and arrive at a different conclusion. Putin and his lackeys, too, looked at the material reality and arrived at the conclusion that Russia must invade. Simply “being evil” is not a material, objective, quantifiable thing. NATO encroaching on the border of Russia, however, is a very material threat to the Russians, whether we think it’s good or bad or justified or not. A threat to their democracy, freedom, and human rights, or whatever buzzwords they use there, you might say.
Anyway it’s really fucking hard to deal with questioning your entire world view. I would know, because I had to go through it, and I really, really, REALLY wanted to stay in the comfy warm hot tub of my previous ideology where everything was easy to explain. But I couldn’t, because once I started asking “why?”, the ideology eventually didn’t hold up any more. Try it. “Yes, but why?” “Because X Y Z.” “Okay, but why? Why X? Where did it come from?”. Go on, ask.
You might not bother to read all this, but that’s fine. I’m kind of posting it for myself anyway.
This comment needs to be pinned somewhere.
Western “freedom” summed up in a single emoji:
deleted by creator