I fully expect NATO to disintegrate because NATO can only exist while the US is committed to the project. The US is increasingly pivoting to Asia now, and once the war is lost then Europe will be left holding the bag. At that point it’s going to become obvious to everyone that the US is not going to protect Europe going forward. The US will do whatever it can to influence Europe, but as we’re already seeing in France, Italy, Germany, Hungary, and Slovakia, the public opinion is increasingly turning against Atlanticism. This trend will only continue gaining momentum going forward, and the more established parties try to play games to stay in power the more the resentment will grow.
That only works as long as the Europeans think they’re better off being vassals of the US rather than make peace with Russia. At the end of the day people care about their material conditions first and foremost. As the standard of living in Europe continues to collapse, the opinion is starting to shift against the US.
European prosperity is reliant on exploitation of other countries, and this exploitation can only be maintained in collaboration with USA. For all the idiocy and pro-Western bootlicking of Russian ruling class, they wouldn’t allow Europeans to exploit their country enough for Europe to maintain its quality of life.
The USA has very little interest in European prosperity, and is currently cannibalizing European industry. The reality is that as western countries lose grip on the rest of the world, it’s going to turn on one another. The US being the biggest fish in the western bloc will prey upon its vassals to bolster its own economy.
EU understands that without the US they are certain to lose their position as the neocolonial metropoly and that their only chance is hoping that they would get some scraps for being good running dogs for the US. Anti-American opposition won’t be significant until after the US loses their hegemony.
I think that’s what the current political class in Europe would want, but they have an uprising on their hands. In particular, both France and Germany are turning increasingly nationalist. Without France and Germany there’s no EU.
At that point it’s going to become obvious to everyone that the US is not going to protect Europe going forward.
I don’t think Ukraine will change the Russophobia of European political leaders and the desire to have a deterrent against an imagined Russian attack. All that othering and saber rattling has tremendous utility in domestic politics. They’ll want to keep NATO for those reasons, and the U.S. will want to keep it to maintain imperial hegemony, so I see it continuing for some time.
I think the person quote in the OP is discounting the extent to which European political leaders are in on the U.S. plan in Ukraine: the fantasy that they can defeat Russia on the battlefield, which will cause a crisis in their government, which will allow Western capital to scoop up a bunch of cheap assets in the country like the bonanza after the fall of the USSR.
That’s my point though, it’s increasingly looking like the current political class is not really in touch with their constituents. And it’s pretty clear that the parties that are gaining momentum are all anti war, and largely anti NATO. Current political establishment absolutely wants to keep doing what they’re doing, but I doubt they will be able to hold on to power for long. What Todd is saying is that the whole current political order is going to collapse.
I fully expect NATO to disintegrate because NATO can only exist while the US is committed to the project. The US is increasingly pivoting to Asia now, and once the war is lost then Europe will be left holding the bag. At that point it’s going to become obvious to everyone that the US is not going to protect Europe going forward. The US will do whatever it can to influence Europe, but as we’re already seeing in France, Italy, Germany, Hungary, and Slovakia, the public opinion is increasingly turning against Atlanticism. This trend will only continue gaining momentum going forward, and the more established parties try to play games to stay in power the more the resentment will grow.
NATO will keep existing precisely because US needs to force Europe to contribute more for maintenance of Western hegemony.
That only works as long as the Europeans think they’re better off being vassals of the US rather than make peace with Russia. At the end of the day people care about their material conditions first and foremost. As the standard of living in Europe continues to collapse, the opinion is starting to shift against the US.
European prosperity is reliant on exploitation of other countries, and this exploitation can only be maintained in collaboration with USA. For all the idiocy and pro-Western bootlicking of Russian ruling class, they wouldn’t allow Europeans to exploit their country enough for Europe to maintain its quality of life.
The USA has very little interest in European prosperity, and is currently cannibalizing European industry. The reality is that as western countries lose grip on the rest of the world, it’s going to turn on one another. The US being the biggest fish in the western bloc will prey upon its vassals to bolster its own economy.
EU understands that without the US they are certain to lose their position as the neocolonial metropoly and that their only chance is hoping that they would get some scraps for being good running dogs for the US. Anti-American opposition won’t be significant until after the US loses their hegemony.
Personally, I don’t think EU is long for this world. We’re already seeing big cracks forming, and it’s only gonna get worse.
Personally, I think EU will openly become an arm of USA.
I think that’s what the current political class in Europe would want, but they have an uprising on their hands. In particular, both France and Germany are turning increasingly nationalist. Without France and Germany there’s no EU.
I don’t think Ukraine will change the Russophobia of European political leaders and the desire to have a deterrent against an imagined Russian attack. All that othering and saber rattling has tremendous utility in domestic politics. They’ll want to keep NATO for those reasons, and the U.S. will want to keep it to maintain imperial hegemony, so I see it continuing for some time.
I think the person quote in the OP is discounting the extent to which European political leaders are in on the U.S. plan in Ukraine: the fantasy that they can defeat Russia on the battlefield, which will cause a crisis in their government, which will allow Western capital to scoop up a bunch of cheap assets in the country like the bonanza after the fall of the USSR.
That’s my point though, it’s increasingly looking like the current political class is not really in touch with their constituents. And it’s pretty clear that the parties that are gaining momentum are all anti war, and largely anti NATO. Current political establishment absolutely wants to keep doing what they’re doing, but I doubt they will be able to hold on to power for long. What Todd is saying is that the whole current political order is going to collapse.