• zed_proclaimer [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    ·
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    (whether on the Israeli flag or not, it’s the same symbol)

    Here’s where your whole shit falls apart and your blatant charlatanism is laid outright. We are talking specifically and only about burning the Israeli flag. We aren’t discussing any other versions of burning the Star of David. A burning Star of David in other contexts is certainly cause for alarm, but not in this one because it’s a symbol of anti-Zionism and anti-Israel, not anti-Judaism. That one sentence literally destroys any point you think you had, exposing you for rhetorical tricks and Zionist pseud arguments conflating the two. We circle back around to you implicitly accepting the Zionist framing that Judaism = Israel.

    I’m Muslim and Muslims are currently under more threat and genocidal pressure than Jews or Christians are, with millions being killed or displaced in recent decades. I would be fine with a burning Turkish flag emoji despite the Muslim symbolism because I don’t believe Turkey = Islam, because I haven’t internalized Turkish narratives. That’s the difference

    • robinn_IV@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      9
      ·
      9 months ago

      You’re just continuing after I pointed out multiple terrible/dishonest arguments you made?

      Here’s where your whole shit falls apart and your blatant charlatanism is laid outright. We are talking specifically and only about burning the Israeli flag.

      Oh my god do you not get it? I know, I’m saying it is still the Star of David. Which is it? Is it that the Zionist state lays the guise of representing Judaism as a shield and adopts symbols representing religion/culture as a farce, or is it that this is completely disconnected? If it’s the former, why do you have an issue with replacing the symbol they’re appropriating/desecrating in the image, and so not allowing it to be spit on further? No, it’s not antisemitism to burn the Israeli flag in resistance to Zionist colonialism, but it’s also not “Zionist brainworms” for a Jewish person to be uncomfortable with the burning of the Star of David even within the Israeli flag.