That’s just more nonsense since none of the core industry was ever privatized or left up to the markets. You are as ignorant as you’re bullheaded.

Also, imagine being so historically illiterate to claim that communists in China made "suffering much worse. This is presumably what you’re referring to.

And what else is there to tell you if you can’t even understand how Walmart example is relevant to the discussion of whether centralization is effective or not.