There will always be people who need transient housing for legitimate reasons;
Sure. But, like, we used to have this idea of dorms in schools where they were an amenity of the school. Similarly, the businesses that need temporarily labor are - functionally - on the hook for the cost of their housing already. Short term housing isn’t a problem unknown to planned economies. Some of the nicest hotels in the world were in the USSR.
I would prefer to see some family get help staying in their own home than see some corporate landlord vacuum more wealth out of communities.
Oh sure, if we’re talking lesser evils. The woman letting her spare room to cover the mortgage pales beside the industrialized slum. But these are both facets of the same structural problem. Artificially constrained and cartelized real estate creates the condition for high market prices. The elderly fixed-income land lady can stake her very tiny claim or withhold it without meaningfully impacting the overall system. She is simply profiting off the cheaply developed real estate of the prior generation, while her college-aged tenant is paying a generational tax for arriving too late to the party.
That being said the whole system of for profit housing needs to be burned down and replaced with housing allocation based on planning and need.
The trick is in striding through that middle period where landladies are held up as the iconic victims of a ruthless Stalin-esque repatriation of private real estate.
Sorry I wasn’t trying to imply disagreement. I just get so sick and tired of seeing people scream about “friendly small landlords!” It’s like the goddamn toothbrush, we really don’t give a shit, and in the end it won’t matter if the larger problem is fixed.
Sure. But, like, we used to have this idea of dorms in schools where they were an amenity of the school. Similarly, the businesses that need temporarily labor are - functionally - on the hook for the cost of their housing already. Short term housing isn’t a problem unknown to planned economies. Some of the nicest hotels in the world were in the USSR.
Oh sure, if we’re talking lesser evils. The woman letting her spare room to cover the mortgage pales beside the industrialized slum. But these are both facets of the same structural problem. Artificially constrained and cartelized real estate creates the condition for high market prices. The elderly fixed-income land lady can stake her very tiny claim or withhold it without meaningfully impacting the overall system. She is simply profiting off the cheaply developed real estate of the prior generation, while her college-aged tenant is paying a generational tax for arriving too late to the party.
The trick is in striding through that middle period where landladies are held up as the iconic victims of a ruthless Stalin-esque repatriation of private real estate.
Sorry I wasn’t trying to imply disagreement. I just get so sick and tired of seeing people scream about “friendly small landlords!” It’s like the goddamn toothbrush, we really don’t give a shit, and in the end it won’t matter if the larger problem is fixed.