I’m reading the introduction, and this comic is pretty accurate. One paragraph is compelling and then the next is the most virulent racism you could possibly write. Some of his conclusions seem to be ignorant of the very thing he just wrote as he is completely blinded by the superiority of Germans or some shit.
Big energy
it’s always nice to remember that a lot of the time, the bits in between the known pages of philosophers is often like 300 pages of extreme racism before their next good idea TM
damn that mneans karl marx had to read through at least 300 pages of extreme racism before stopping, hmmm
Cedric Robinson thought that an unconscious German nationalism on Marx and Engles’ part hindred their analysis of nationalism, so there’s that.
That’s mildly true in their early years, but it’s overstated, and it was completely excised after the failures of 1848
The ratio of racist to interesting in this text isn’t quite that high, otherwise I’d have stopped reading it quickly. I did put it down halfway though after reading several pages of garbage, and then picked it up again once I forgot about it.
Hegels racism was pre-darwinian too, so it gets real weird.
I remember when I was reading Schopenhauer’s World as Will and Representation and Artie is talking about some deep stuff but then suddenly jumps into a rant about Jews.
Wild.
Martin Luther 1523:
Martin Luther 1543:
marty really hit his stride after getting adopted by germanic princes that were really into not paying the church but still really hated jewish people
Man Martin Luther was my first role model, I guess you shield your child from certain realities until they become a bit older. I was taught in sunday school about him all the time. About his views on forgiveness (freely given, not earned) on baptism (choosing a religion must be a free choice) and so on. Then one day me and my dad are discussing Dietrich Bonhoeffer and the role of the church in Nazi Germany when I think 13 year old me still full in fanboy mode says “Man if only Martin Luther had been alive to see what became of the church he founded, he’d have put a stop to this”. The moment my dad looked at me with sad pity and started off with this “Well…” was just brutal. Like full on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fXLicO0CRvk .
Good wake up call though, if someone as learned and critical of his own belief as Martin Luther could succumb to what is in my view such an obvious sin, then what kind of brainworms might be lurking in my mind??