I’m saying that both are authoritarian. Both are incompatible with Democracy and the current rules based international order, which when working correctly can prevent genocide from occurring (i.e. if the UN peacekeeping missions actually do their job).
the Bogus moral equivalence of the Holocaust has been from the time of the actual massacres the myth that the Jews were all Communists and got what they deserved because Communism was every bit as genocidal as Nazism. Hence what the Jews call the Holocaust is a kind of opposite and equal reaction to the first genocide, the crimes of Communism.
First of all, this was not what I was implying. I never said that Communists were equally as genocidal as Nazis, nor that I deny that the Holocaust occurred. Putting words in my mouth is arguing in bad faith.
I am saying that the Tankies on the left support the same type of authoritarian policies that are prevalent on the right. While actions like, for example, the Tiananmen square massacre are not as large in scope as the Holocaust, accepting the CCP party line on the issue is antithetical to human rights, just as any massacre is. Supporting authoritarian regimes that do this is, in fact, just as bad regardless of whether the party is “left” or “right”.
Did the Holocaust occur? Yes. Did it result in the death of millions of Jews at the hands of the Nazis? Yes. I’m not disputing any of these facts, so please do not suggest that I am denying the Holocaust.
Dude, you are missing the point. The Communists that support authoritarian regimes which kill people are morally equivalent to fascists who support the same. I do not retract my statement as it isn’t incorrect.
Also, you’ve spammed your original comment to me all over the main thread, implying that a lot of us here deny the Holocaust. Please don’t do this, it makes you look like an ass.
Not everyone on the internet is a guy, stop treating it as the default.
The Communists that support authoritarian regimes which kill people are morally equivalent to fascists who support the same. I do not retract my statement as it isn’t incorrect.
Okay, thank you for admitting to being the type of guy the Jewish holocaust scholar is complaining about. Have a good day.
When did I say I was minimizing the Holocaust?
I’m saying that both are authoritarian. Both are incompatible with Democracy and the current rules based international order, which when working correctly can prevent genocide from occurring (i.e. if the UN peacekeeping missions actually do their job).
What rules? Who do I report the USA to for repeatedly violating all of the rules and killing millions of people around the globe?
You are equating them. Read the link from the mainstream Jewish holocaust scholar to understand why that’s holocaust trivialization.
First of all, this was not what I was implying. I never said that Communists were equally as genocidal as Nazis, nor that I deny that the Holocaust occurred. Putting words in my mouth is arguing in bad faith.
I am saying that the Tankies on the left support the same type of authoritarian policies that are prevalent on the right. While actions like, for example, the Tiananmen square massacre are not as large in scope as the Holocaust, accepting the CCP party line on the issue is antithetical to human rights, just as any massacre is. Supporting authoritarian regimes that do this is, in fact, just as bad regardless of whether the party is “left” or “right”.
Did the Holocaust occur? Yes. Did it result in the death of millions of Jews at the hands of the Nazis? Yes. I’m not disputing any of these facts, so please do not suggest that I am denying the Holocaust.
You literally said this
You are free to retract this. Could you say for me “Communists are in no way morally equivalent to fascists”?
Also to be clear I’m accusing you of trivializing the holocaust not denying the holocaust.
Dude, you are missing the point. The Communists that support authoritarian regimes which kill people are morally equivalent to fascists who support the same. I do not retract my statement as it isn’t incorrect.
Also, you’ve spammed your original comment to me all over the main thread, implying that a lot of us here deny the Holocaust. Please don’t do this, it makes you look like an ass.
Not everyone on the internet is a guy, stop treating it as the default.
Okay, thank you for admitting to being the type of guy the Jewish holocaust scholar is complaining about. Have a good day.
sigh
Hope you have a good day as well.
Arguing with Hexbears sure is exhausting, isn’t it?
Yeah. Tell me about it.
Removed by mod
Removed by mod
Removed by mod