Disclaimer: I don’t think I’m the target audience for this game
Picked this game up (on sale) for my partner who is a low-key potter head. Been playing for the past couple of weeks together and it’s been…interesting (still fun though).
First Impression: 1. The player controls and game mechanics make this game near unplayable. From the start to about midgame, the way a character moves or how you navigate menus/controls just drives you absolutely nuts. 2. The actual “Hogwarts” classes fucking suck, there’s no comparison on how badly they failed at these. 3. The game is mercilessly plagued by bugs (some annoying, others game breaking).
This was all before actually looking into the game online. I heard when it was originally being developed, but kinda lost sight of it once it actually came out. I couldn’t believe when I saw it was “Game of the Year” for so many outlets and awards. I will admit the depth of the spell system and work that went into it is pretty neat. If that was their main goal then they squashed it.
After spending so much time on it and seeing it through a fan’s eyes and reading about it, I’m just confused on if this is a great game or something that fell short (and hopefully then improved upon for the sequel). Puzzles: I have a few that haven’t been solved yet, sometimes I think a puzzle is extremely deep then I find something that gives you the answer with no thought (or the voice overs tell you what to do before you have a chance to look at it). I’m trying not to spoil any Easter eggs or hard puzzles but part of me is worried I’m looking at this deeper than I’m supposed to be and all of this just actually sucks. I did COD Zombie EE’s and that shit gets deep, I’m holding out hope and continuing to try and do more on my own.
A huge caveat: I purchased this through the switch store, and it should have absolutely not had a switch release! Load times are extremely painful, graphics are completely shit, and I suspect all the bugs and crashes I’ve gotten are from trying to play it on a switch. PC play and mods probably make this a completely different game.
Everything else on it is pretty standard and/or substandard. Shitty “Open-world!!” that’s a failed perspective (enemies basically in the backyards of the town, way too clustered), they litter the map with repeats or useless shit (who else tried the skipping stones or various “Interactive Items” for hours till giving up on all of them?). Gear and equipment is shit and the upgrade/trait system is pretty “primary school level” thought process. Capacity for everything is abysmal especially for a “magic” world and improving the limited capacity is pretty “fetch quest” level of enjoyment.
Context: Just basically in the late game now trying to 100% everything before doing the last two main quests since the interest in completing it after might not be there.
TL;DR, semi-decent buy on sale especially if you’re into the potter lore. Subpar rpg/adventure game: If you’re casual, wait for a sequel where it will probably have all the systems improved.
I 100%ed the game and as I was reading your review I was like “Wait, something’s off… this isn’t the game I played on PS5…”
Then I saw:
“A huge caveat: I purchased this through the switch store, and it should have absolutely not had a switch release!”
Oh… yeah… Oh no. Now it makes sense. Yeah, the game was never intended for the Switch and compromises were made.
The first 4k video of gameplay I saw blew my mind lol. You can actually see depth and aren’t confused squinting at a low res model trying to figure out what you’re looking at from a small distance. I was shocked when we first played BOTW and it’s problems running properly (lots of lag for a game made for the system), this title made me realize the switch is just dead to me now.
Yeah, I was about to say the game was surprisingly great. Seeing the op played it on the switch, I can understand the subpar experience.
I played on PC, and had a great time. Like the other person said, it wasn’t intended for such a casual machine.
I really liked the interactive items, even though they were useless. It was fun to try roleplaying as a student sometimes. I didn’t find the enemies to be too clustered either. My personal favorite thing was flying around on the broom. The game world is pretty big so you have plenty of room to just do your thing.
