Cuomo in NY during COVID forced the production of hand sanitizer by slaveprison labor and Gruesome Newsom forces slaveprison labor to fight forest fires so you know what, maybe the 14th amendment kind of sucks because it lets everyone pretend that slavery did get abolished and it’s a “solved problem”
So yeah you know what fuck it, let the fascists rule that a constitutional amendment is unconstitutional and blow up the Constitution through a paradox (how can the constitution itself be unconstitutional?)
That’s not the 14th amendment, you’re thinking of the 13th. The 14th amendment gives equal protection and birthright citizenship, and the latter sections are all about how the US doesn’t owe any confederate debts nor can ex-confederates hold federal office.
It’s far worse. IMHO it would have the most far-reaching consequences of any amendment if repealed. Section 1 alone would overturn a massive amount of case law.
Section 1. All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside. No State shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
In addition to the obvious part that it would be perfectly legal to arbitrarily revoke citizenship, discriminate, etc., the due process clause as it applies to the states (the one in the Fifth Amendment applies to feds only) is out the window. For instance, states and private entities are now free to violate any of the Bill of Rights because there’s no incorporation doctrine to push back against Barron v. Baltimore (1833).
Cuomo in NY during COVID forced the production of hand sanitizer by
slaveprison labor and Gruesome Newsom forcesslaveprison labor to fight forest fires so you know what, maybe the 14th amendment kind of sucks because it lets everyone pretend that slavery did get abolished and it’s a “solved problem”So yeah you know what fuck it, let the fascists rule that a constitutional amendment is unconstitutional and blow up the Constitution through a paradox (how can the constitution itself be unconstitutional?)
That’s not the 14th amendment, you’re thinking of the 13th. The 14th amendment gives equal protection and birthright citizenship, and the latter sections are all about how the US doesn’t owe any confederate debts nor can ex-confederates hold federal office.
It’s far worse. IMHO it would have the most far-reaching consequences of any amendment if repealed. Section 1 alone would overturn a massive amount of case law.
In addition to the obvious part that it would be perfectly legal to arbitrarily revoke citizenship, discriminate, etc., the due process clause as it applies to the states (the one in the Fifth Amendment applies to feds only) is out the window. For instance, states and private entities are now free to violate any of the Bill of Rights because there’s no incorporation doctrine to push back against Barron v. Baltimore (1833).
Yep, losing incorporation would truly be mayhem. Seems like the way a balkanizing USA would go though.
Yep whoops
Dogma (1999)