Edit: Update 2024-10-30

Let it be known that Mr. Alexandru was very patient with me and resolved everything for me by upgrading his infrastructure a few days later. I really appreciate it!


blob-on-fire

TankieTube is suffering from success.

  • GaveUp [she/her]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    so I’ve never actually used nginx or made any application 0-1 so I can’t help with the actual work, just general architecture advice since I only code for work

    anyways, I think the nginx config I was talking about is proxy_cache_min_uses

    So the idea is that in real life content hosting, a lot of resources only get accessed once and never again for a long time (think some guy scrolling obscure context late at night cause they’re bored af), so you don’t want these to be filling up your cache

    It will take a lot of time to develop but you can optimize for that fact that videos/context are often either 1 hit wonders like the aforementioned scenario or have short lived popularity. I.e. a video gets posted to hexbear, a hundred people view this video over 1 week so you want to cache it, but then after the post gets buried, the video fades back into obscurity, and so you don’t want this thing to outlive its usefulness in the cache

    There are some strategies to do this. This new FIFO queue replacement policy deals with the 1 hit wonder situation https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3600006.3613147

    Another strategy you can implement, which is what YouTube implements, is that they use an LRU cache, but they only cache a new item when a video gets requested from 2 unique clients and the time between those 2 requests are shorter than the last retrieved time of the oldest item in the LRU cache (which they track in a persistent metadata track along with other info. you can read the paper above to get an idea of what a metadata cache would store). They also wrote a math proof that supports this algorithm being better than a typical LRU cache

    Also I assume nginx/you are probably already going this but caching what a user sees on the site before clicking into a video should all be prioritized over the actual videos. I.e. thumbnails, video titles, view count, etc. Users will scroll through a ton of videos but only click on a very few amount of videos, so you get more use of the cache this way

    I’ll try to dig through my brain and try to remember other optimizations YouTube does that is also feasible for tankie tube and let you know as many details as I can remember. This is all just my memory from reading their internal engineering docs when I used to have access. Most of it is just based on having a fuckload of CDNs around the entire world and the best hardware though

    • TankieTanuki [he/him]@hexbear.netOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 month ago

      That’s a good idea for the caching strategy, thanks! I’ll research how to implement it in nginx.

      As for your professional friend, right now I’m more limited by money than time or technical skills, so I’m going to hack away for a little longer.