• maegul (he/they)
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    We don’t see much of the Portal Stones after book 2 to be fair, and that’s not really a spoiler.

    That doesn’t surprise me. It felt really janky in the book, like I said above, it’s as though Jordan just needed to get Rand to Cairhein quickly, and any deeper plot points would probably have felt like derivative parallel universes stuff.

    Not to whine too much about the books so far, but the ending of Book 1 established that I might not make it through the series because it seemed like a rushed blunder and didn’t bode well for the series, and while I’m enjoying book 2, that portals world thing with super-on-the-nose Selene out of no where really emphasises the sentiment. I’ll reserve judgment until the end of book 2, with my general aim being to finish book 4 (as that’s apparently when the series really starts), but that portals world with selene sequence really did feel like some low tier fantasy. Like worse than anything in book 1. I’m honestly sad that portal world isn’t some deeper plot point because it feels like quite a taint on book 2 and I’m surprised I hadn’t heard anything about it.

    • abraxas@sh.itjust.worksOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      Sorry for the double-reply, but I noticed something worth covering.

      the ending of Book 1 established that I might not make it through the series because it seemed like a rushed blunder

      The ending of book 1 is absolutely the worst scene in the entire series. Try not to judge it too hard from it. Jordan was convinced he would not get renewed to complete his series, and planned for that eventuality. The Eye climax was written to be epic enough and give enough closure that he could sleep at night if he didn’t get a book 2. He did similar for Book 3, but with years more forethought and so it’s written better.

      • maegul (he/they)
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        Oh I figured … I try not to judge it too harshly … it’s mostly that it was pretty jarring for a celebrated series.

        Interesting to hear about book 3 … was it not clear he would be able to continue the series afterwards?

        • abraxas@sh.itjust.worksOPM
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          Yeah. Long-running fantasy series were rare in the late 80’s and early 90’s. Fantasy was still largely bargain-bin tier alongside Harlequin Romance. A few people tried, but Wheel of Time is arguably only the second Epic Fantasy to ever get mainstream respect. Even Epic Sci-Fi was risky. Before Wheel of Time opened the door, the only other Epic than LotR that got any respect at all was Shannara… and it would never have gotten a $100M television budget (aSoIaF opened the door for that, but it’s not technically Epic Fantasy, either). I mean, Riftwar Saga got a video game (Betrayal at Krondor), but people remember the game more than the books.

          So suffice to say, publishers were very weak on promises, and generally only signed books with a beginning, a middle, and an end. Renewals were incredibly rare and far between. Ironically, we had a couple great masterpieces back then, but they didn’t get marketed or remembered like they can now.

    • abraxas@sh.itjust.worksOPM
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      That doesn’t surprise me. It felt really janky in the book, like I said above, it’s as though Jordan just needed to get Rand to Cairhein quickly, and any deeper plot points would probably have felt like derivative parallel universes stuff.

      I think he was trying to do something plot-important, and those Mirror Worlds are representative of something important that I think he does with other things. There’s more, but you’re not late enough in book 2 for me to discuss it with you without spoilers yet.

      that portals world thing with super-on-the-nose Selene out of no where really emphasises the sentiment

      When you’re done with Book 2, let me know and I might be able to give you a different take on this :) There are theories that were never confirmed/denied here.

      I’ll reserve judgment until the end of book 2, with my general aim being to finish book 4 (as that’s apparently when the series really starts)

      I would say the series really starts early in book 4. Book 4 is largely considered the best book in the series, and it’s the big character-growth book for several major players.

      but that portals world with selene sequence really did feel like some low tier fantasy

      Without spoilers (see above), I think it was intended to feel like low-tier fantasy.

      • maegul (he/they)
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        1 year ago

        When you’re done with Book 2, let me know and I might be able to give you a different take on this

        Will do!

        • abraxas@sh.itjust.worksOPM
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          edit-2
          1 year ago

          Actually, you’re already through S2E5, right? So…

          Spoiler through S2E4, theory about Portal Stones and Selene

          Of course it’s on the nose. Rand didn’t accidentally channel there. Lanfear intentionally channeled him there, and made it look like it was him so she could have time with him and manipulate him (away from those around him).

          There was no “win” for plot by him getting to Cairhien before the hunters. It was a win for one of the Forsaken to get him (mostly) alone.

          And as for opportunity… THAT we can discuss after you finish The Great Hunt… or maybe a lot later I’m not sure. My theory on how Rand got to a Portal Stone at all is a lot more spoilery and more of a stretch.

          • maegul (he/they)
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            1 year ago
            Spoiler through S2E4, theory about Portal Stones and Selene

            Thanks! I figured as much re Lanfear … part of why I say the whole thing is a bit on the nose. The moment she turns up and even Rand is confused about how she managed to defend herself against the monster you know she’s behind Rand getting there. The reason I called it a dream land of some sort was I figured it might have even been a special construct of Lanfear’s.

            The only thing that muddies the waters about what the portal land actually is or if for … is the movements of Fain and his group. It’s not clear (at this point in the book) why they’re zig-zagging around (it being Lanfear’s directions would be my best guess ATM??) and what it means that Hurin could pick up they’re scent in the portal world at what seems to be ahead of their actual arrival.

            As to how Rand ended up a portal stone … that seems way too spoilery for me at this point!

            Thanks again!!

            • abraxas@sh.itjust.worksOPM
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              2
              ·
              edit-2
              1 year ago

              part of why I say the whole thing is a bit on the nose

              Pretty quickly you’re realizing that Lanfear is simultaneously the most devious of the forsaken and the most immature. She wanted to be the princess swept off her feet by the reincarnation of her old jilted lover. I know “princesses” like that, and I’m sure you do. Imagine if that princess had a 150 IQ and was the most powerful sorceress in known human history. Jordan practically invented the modern practice of turning fantasy tropes on their head, and that’s what he did here with Selene… In a way that I think he intended to be really obvious. But maybe could have been a bit less obvious anyway.

              The reason I called it a dream land of some sort was I figured it might have even been a special construct of Lanfear’s.

              Ahhh… I never thought of it that way. You’ve probably already realized from our conversation that it isn’t a construct of hers, but it would make a lot of sense if it had been.

              It’s not clear (at this point in the book) why they’re zig-zagging around

              My opinion is that he’s playing possum. But also… the fade nailed to a wall was meant to be an obvious change of leadership (which means change of plans).

              and what it means that Hurin could pick up they’re scent in the portal world at what seems to be ahead of their actual arrival.

              A regular idea of Jordan’s is that “time works differently in other worlds”. It genuinely may be no deeper than that, consistent throughout the books. We don’t get too much info into the workings of sniffers, unfortunately.

              As to how Rand ended up a portal stone … that seems way too spoilery for me at this point!

              Yup :). I can say that it’s all theory and never specifically said. So mere chance (with Lanfear being opportunistic) is possible. Like waygates, portal stones are somewhat common. Unlike waygates, the commonness of portal stones doesn’t matter much. Waygates are important to the story in ways that I know Jordan had already considered when he introduced one in book 1 (spoilers through aMoL, so stopping there).