The 10GBase-LR is 1310nm and the QSFP-40G-LR4 CWDM channels are 1271, 1291, 1311 and 1331 nm. Are the 1310nm and 3rd channel 1311nm technically compatible?

I have a 10Gb and (will eventually have) a 40Gb switch both fitted with basic LR (Q)SFP+ transceivers and want to know if I can directly connect them or will I have to use an adapter to fit an SFP+ in an QSFP+ port?

I’m looking at using the XQX2502 QSFP+.

  • Sailing7
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    I’m not thaat into networking so excuse my possibly dumb question: is there a DAC Cable on the market, that would enable you to skip all that?

    To this topic i found this:

    English Article Version: https://community.fs.com/blog/how-to-convert-a-port-from-qsfp-to-sfp-port.html

    German Article Version: https://community.fs.com/de/blog/how-to-convert-a-port-from-qsfp-to-sfp-port.html

    The pictures suggest, that you could do exactly that (SFP+ to QSFP+). I’m not sure though, what that cable would be.

    Edit: the article is in german. Try the new firefox translate feature, it should work. Edit2: added the english version of the article

    • ky56@aussie.zoneOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      Yes. There is also an adapter that would allow me to use a SFP+ in a QSFP+ port. But I’m trying to work out if I can make an easily interoperable system where a wall jack fed from a 40G switch can act as a both a 10G or 40G port as needed. Hence the question.

      QSFP+ to SFP+: MTP/MPO-LC Breakout Cable

      This is almost the setup I’m looking for. Except example is using MMF. I want to know is this setup can be done to one SFP over SMF.

      • gramathy
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        3
        ·
        1 year ago

        Unless specifically stated, generally fiber transceivers only run at the stated rate and would expect every channel to negotiate unless it had a 4x10 mode supported by both the transceiver and the device you put it in (which is what that DAC splitter is for), though once you split the lanes this way, a single pair would only ever run at 10g

        Additionally the nature of CWDM on a single pair means the 10g side will see all four signals simultaneously as there are no filters on that side of the connection. QSFP+ runs like this because it’s cheaper to manufacture and a single transmit/receive pair is only necessary in much longer range transport which typically uses more specialized expensive hardware for better long range signal integrity.

        In short: no, this won’t work and transceivers generally only ever run in one mode et once as configure by the switch/router they’re inserted in, and the modes you’re asking a qsfp+ to run in are mutually exclusive based on type (single lc pair cwdm at 40g vs 4x10g MPO/MTP with changeable modes). Fiber doesn’t have the same “negotiation” features that copper Ethernet does.

        • Sailing7
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          1 year ago

          I didnt ask his question, though i a want to thank you for answering it. I learned a lot in this thread :D