Materialism>idealism

I’m not trying to get into a whole debate, it’s just interesting to me the way some people cling to these idealist philosophers. Same w the stoics imo. As a guy who used to read all of them… they’re useless to actually understanding life. Like it can be helpful to read them in order to understand how the Western worldview evolved, but they really shouldn’t be taken as some sort of handbook - which many seem to do. (reactionaries). People who read Nietzsche or Plato and think they have some sort of secret insight is my biggest red flag irt pseudo-intellectual who is just going to waste your time… same with Dostoevsky btw.

Confucius is based af though.

Edit: Also, yes these kinds of people exist- my former mentor/boss who spent decades at a white shoe DC law firm would accept any idea if you found a quote by Plato to justify it lmao.

  • OrnluWolfjarl@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    9
    ·
    2 years ago

    People tend to forget that ancient Greek philosophers were… well, ancient. It’s useful to read their works and some of them do still have ideas that can apply today. For example, the stoic approach of “you make your own misfortune” is relevant to mental health today to a certain degree. Or Thucidedes’ approach to chronicling the Peloponnesian war has a very materialist approach.

    But ofcourse, they lived in an age where slavery was acceptable and the main form of government was a mixture of oligarchy and monarchy. The ancient Greek world was chronically afflicted by steady xenophobia and women were largely seen as property (with the possible exception of Sparta where women were likely the economical elite). And ofcourse most people didn’t tend to know a whole lot about the physical world around them. It’s only natural that the bulk of these thinkers were idealists and propping up the elite. Their ideas on politics, economics, and to a large extent, science are pretty much outdated. There’s no denying, however, that they set the stage for future advancements, including Marxism. Marx’s ideas were largely formed in his younger years, by thinking and refuting the idealism and elitism of the Ancient Greek world and its offspring in contemporary Western thinking.