Includes fan favorites like:

  • showing anarchists blabbering on about their fear about political oppression under a supposed Russian occupation while in reality every left-wing party in Ukraine has been outlawed a couple weeks ago and the SBU has arrested and locked up prominent communist activists after the start of the war
  • trivializing the very real nazi problem in Ukraine when literal fascist militias like Azov are not just some randos fighting in this war but officially part of the Ukrainian defense forces and Ukrainian fascists have high political positions with them being a driving force in the civil war waged against the people in the Donbas
  • the lame “but Zelenskyy is a jew”-argument when antisemitism and hatecrimes against other minorities like Roma and LGBT-people have been on a steady rise since 2014
  • suggesting that the Russians are in a war frenzy showing some TV clips as proof while completely ignoring the huge anti-war protests in Russia and the real political oppression of anti-war-activists in Russia

This video offers zero critical investigation and just regurgitates the usual Ukrainian handwaving and anti-Russian propaganda with some nice emotional manipulation to really tug at the heartstrings.

  • Comrade Boina
    link
    fedilink
    6
    edit-2
    2 years ago

    Also btw on the first point:

    It wasn’t only left wing parties banned a couple weeks ago, it was ALL opposition parties remotely tied to being committed in respecting the minsk accords, along with russian-minority parties. It very much includes right wing parties.

    the vast majority of real left wing communist elements were banned since immediately after the maidan coup, the communist party of ukraine comes to mind.

    It’s “interesting” that anarchists faced nowhere near that level of repression. What is also interesting is that “OG” Ukrainian anarchists were purged during the Maidan coup and directly after. Many at first fell for the Maidan movement and thought it was to be worked with, to tragic situations: they were directly attacked and murdered in the occupation protest.

    I’m willing to bet most anarchists from that period are dead, or left the country. The “anarchists” in Ukraine fighting for Zelensky and Azov are provably mostly football ultras and hooligans, who 1) were never really political and 2) grew up after the coup and were DEEPLY propagandized. I’m therefore also willing to bet they are left to exist because they pose even less of a threat actual anarchists represent for bourgeois states, and that they are deeply infiltrated by fascists / ukraine security elements, and that they serve as propaganda to fuck with the international left and divide it (as in: get dumb western anarchists/soc dems to say: “look, the ukrainian left is fighting against russia, neither Zelensky or Putin! Back the Anarchists! Biji Rojava!”, even when we know well these supposed “anarchists” serve fascism and the Ukrainian state, knowlingly so or not it doesn’t matter).

    • Comrade BirbOP
      link
      fedilink
      62 years ago

      Yeah I kinda glossed over some details in my initial post, only concentrating on the elements not commonly reported in the western mainstream. The situation of the political left in Ukraine since the maidan coup has been dire, to say the least.

      I won’t knock the actual mutual aid stuff these supposed anarchists are doing but they seem fishy to me as well. I mean their takes in the interviews are just incredibly bad. I was intent on ignoring this video but the “political repression under Russian occupation” bit from that first anarkiddie actually made me angry lol

  • Comrade Boina
    link
    fedilink
    52 years ago

    Is that the all gas no break guy?

    Disappointing, not surprised tho.

    Many of those quirky youtubers end up scoring a “journalism” job at a bourgeois news channel. They use their previous work as a way to line their resume.

    • Comrade BirbOP
      link
      fedilink
      62 years ago

      Yeah it’s the same guy/team. AFAIK they had to abandon the initial channel because of some dispute with their content network or something. Channel 5 is just their new name.

      • Comrade Boina
        link
        fedilink
        3
        edit-2
        2 years ago

        Ah fair, well if that last video doesn’t score him a “real journalism” job I don’t know what will lol.

        Edit: probably at vice lmfao

        • Comrade BirbOP
          link
          fedilink
          52 years ago

          Considering that Jake Hanrahan (the guy he’s interviewing throughout the video) is reporting with Vice… not implausible lol