This is a device category I have very little knowledge about, but I have a growing collection of PDFs and ebooks and I’d love to have a light weight device to read them on.
Any recommendations? Are they all walled gardens?
You must log in or # to comment.
Seconded. Some older kindles can also be jailbroken. But Kobos in general are good. You might want to avoid Onyx, they’re known violators of GPL
Violating GPL as in copyright laws? How is that not based?
GPL is the one that requires you to freely publish your changes to the source code for others to use. its not based to make it much harder to maintain the device once the manufacturer decides to drop support.
Oh OK violating GPL not as in failing to respect intellectual property, but as failing to publish the shit you do, got it
These look really nice and exactly what I’m looking for. Its funny, my SO is laughing because she used to sell these at Borders book store years ago, she said they couldn’t compete with kindals at the time. Looks like they’re doing well now though!
I like Boox but they are on the more pricey side. Basically an android tablet with an e-ink display.
Seconding Boox, I have a Note Air and I love it. Definitely pricy but it has everything I want
Edit: one of the reasons I went with Boox is that I wanted good PDF support, and the large screen lets you view them easily
I went the Boox way more than half a decade ago. Personally, the 2 draws were:
- The availability of bigger screens: at 10.3’', the Note 1 was great for A4/Letter PDFs, and I just liked to have a big wall of small text for my epubs.
- The freedom from walled-garden: I could use whatever Android app to read whatever format.
Other will probably tout the note-taking, the possibility to use a real browser, the versatility of an e-ink tablet, etc. But those are not my main use case.
They are on the expensive side though, and my very plasticky Note 1 sadly died after only a short handful of years. The latest Boox offerings have metal casings though, so they might be more durable.
I’ve been reading on my mobile since my Note 1 died, but I could finally splurge on a Go 10.3 recently. That big, non-backlighted screen is glorious and so restful after a day on computer and mobile screens ❤️
For my next one, I might go bigger (13’') and colour - if colour e-ink improves markedly - for comic books consumption. But I hope I can rock the Go 10.3 for the better part of a decade this time 🤞
(PS: Calibre and ePub for the win!)
I have sung praises of kobo ereaders many times before. You can go to the search and look for comments made by me that say “kobo”.
I don’t know any the new models though so check on that. The gist is that they are not locked down so you can read pirated ebooks on them.
I’m not sure about PDFs. Because of their nature I’ve not tried to read them on an ereader.
I’ve got a kobo that’s 5ish years old now and its been solid. Pirated soooooo many books with it. My particular model doesn’t really love pdf, but its technically capable
Go on ebay and grab a Kobo Aura. Then download Calibre to your computer. Then go to Libgen for any book you want
and annas-archive, which is basically a clone of libgen, z-library, and sci-hub
Kindles suck thanks to Amazon lock in, but I pirate all my books and use Calibre to convert/manage my library, and can easily use email to send books to my device. The main reason I stick with this one (paper white) is the battery life. I go a month or two between charges, reading heavily. My wife’s Kobo needs to be charged every couple weeks and she’s a much lighter reader than me.
I would suggest a Kobo e-reader, their cheap model is perfect imo.
If you would like to add more options to the software, there’s open source software you can easily side load called “Ko-Reader”, navigating pdf files is much easier than stock for example.
As far as walled gardens go, you can easily sync ebooks with your computer using Calibre to manage your library. You can also add books when out and about using your phone as a mobile hotspot if you enable the beta web browser on the kobo and use https://send.djazz.se/
Editing to add: I always either convert my pdf’s into epub’s using calibre or pirate the epubs directly, there aren’t many e-readers that do PDF’s well, and those are all pretty expensive. Things like the Onyx Boox or Sony’s Digital Paper Series
I always either convert my pdf’s into epub’s using calibre or pirate the epubs directly
Yeah that’s my plan now. I also know there is a Calibre-Web project that turns it into a self hosted website where you can do most of what Calibre desktop dose, but in your browser.
That’s very interesting, I wasn’t aware of that! I prefer adding books without having to boot up my desktop, definitely looking into this
I already do some home server stuff so this seemed like the ideal solution.
PDFs are hard because you need a big e-reader screen. Text only formats like Epub or Mobi are much easier. If you think you can find epubs for all the PDFs you want to read, I’d recommend getting an old Kindle. I’m partial to the Kindle Touch (which can be jailbroken easily). You can often find them for around 20 USD on eBay, which is the cheapest you can get something like this.
I think I can get epub versions of most of the stuff I want to read. When I first started collecting books I had no idea what an epub file was and avoided them.
If the PDFs are mainly just text - the text can be ripped out/converted.
But so many PDFs are complicated. Basically web sites, with forms, embedded images and so on that displaying may be a nightmare.
I got a kobo after a recommendation here, and it reads pdfs fine enough for me
The boox readers appear to be the best because they have a full android rom, but they’re expensive. My experience with Kobo has been bad, I’ve had 3 devices fail for various reasons even though they’re quite a bit more expensive than Kindle.
I’ve since switched to a refurbished Kindle Oasis, which is a great piece of hardware for the money. Top notch screen, light, great form factor, real buttons that are well placed. It’s got the stupid Amazon ecosystem, but I don’t pay for books, so it doesn’t bother me, I just don’t use it. They still give you an email address so you can easily send books from calibre without needing to plug it in.
what sort of PDFs do you need to read? are they comic books, illustrated magazines, scientific articles? do you need to take hand written notes or do markups?
Often older books I have accumulated are PDFs, with poor ocr. That’s mostly where the PDFs come from. I know there are probably better eBook versions that I can find to replace the old book scans.
I also have a Kobo :) I think a Clara? It was pretty cheap, but I can’t email files to it, have to transfer via USB
I got a Kobo Libra and immediately put KOReader on there. Works great and jailbreaking is extremely easy.
I had a kobo Clara colour but broke the screen (no idea how).
I replaced it with a Book poke 4 lite and that’s better IMO, but the kobo was good.
Ideally you’ll want one that isnt locked into any ecosystem so you can do what you want on it.
I uſe a Kobo Libra 2 with KoReader, and Calibre to edit and convert e-books. It’s not as large as ſome other models ; ſo it wouldn’t be as well-ſuited to PDFs or certain textbooks, but as as been ſaid elſewhere in the thread, it’s not unreaſonable to convert thoſe to e-pub or mobi for a better experience. What it does have as a benefit over ſome other e-readers at the moment is a higher contraſt ratio and generally good reſolution—not quite as nice as a print book, but very cloſe. The ſcreen itſelf ends up being cloſer to a newſpaper in print quality than a nice book due to the tint and general contraſt, but this can be a bit leſs apparent with brighter lighting or direct ſunlight. It’s an overall nice experience and can act as a replacement for phyſical books, but both methods have their advantages and diſadvantages.
