Meritocracy has become a leading social ideal. Politicians across the ideological spectrum continually return to the theme that the rewards of life—money, power, jobs, university admission—should be distributed according to skill and effort.
Not if (as the article rightly points out) it helps upholding and justifying current elite power with the illusion of merit. It is exactly this naive thinking that the “best” system automatically wins, when in reality our world works nothing like that.
So what would you propose as an alternative? Should we go back to nepotism? I feel like a flawed implementation of meritocracy is better than openly accepting nepotism again.
What makes you think our current system isn’t mostly based on nepotism? What exactly do you want to go “back” to?
And even if you are lucky to be based in a slightly more meritocratic society, you argument is similar to someone saying “Should we go back to monarchism? I feel like a flawed implementation of capitalism is better than openly accepting monarchy again.” Which is a false dichotomy.
And no, I am not going to spoon-feed you viable alternatives, because apparently you are still stuck in the TINA mindset, which you first need to discard.
Not if (as the article rightly points out) it helps upholding and justifying current elite power with the illusion of merit. It is exactly this naive thinking that the “best” system automatically wins, when in reality our world works nothing like that.
So what would you propose as an alternative? Should we go back to nepotism? I feel like a flawed implementation of meritocracy is better than openly accepting nepotism again.
What makes you think our current system isn’t mostly based on nepotism? What exactly do you want to go “back” to?
And even if you are lucky to be based in a slightly more meritocratic society, you argument is similar to someone saying “Should we go back to monarchism? I feel like a flawed implementation of capitalism is better than openly accepting monarchy again.” Which is a false dichotomy.
And no, I am not going to spoon-feed you viable alternatives, because apparently you are still stuck in the TINA mindset, which you first need to discard.