1. I am very unlikely to switch away from KDE Plasma 6
  2. I would anyways like to try Sway or the like
  3. I dont use virtual desktops and find just navigating through a bottom taskbar makes more sense for me
  4. I have many apps fullscreen, and would never tile more than once vertically, as I am on a Laptop
  5. I want: NightLight, tray icons, a good app menu, many KDE Apps (Dolphin, Kate, Ark, Gwenview, Spectacle Edit feature at least)

Are Wayland WMs ready for this use case? What would you recommend to fill these exact requirements?

  • boredsquirrel@slrpnk.netOP
    1·
    6 months ago

    Haha no not really.

    I look forward to pure Rust COSMIC, which works pretty well. But they need to do so much ground work, and their UX (overview, app menu, …) is in parts pretty ugly.

    I wonder what the best alternative to KWin is. Wayfire? Labwc?

    • Ephera
      2·
      6 months ago

      Well, I haven’t tried any of them. Apparently, LabWC is built to work similarly to Openbox, which I used before switching to KDE Plasma.

      Openbox could do most things that Kwin could, although it had some big omissions, like no way to tile a window by dragging it to the screen edge (you could set up a keyboard shortcut to resize and move a window, though).

      According to the LXQt link above, it also doesn’t have desktop effects, if you want/need those.

      But yeah, I know nothing about Wayfire…

      • boredsquirrel@slrpnk.netOP
        1·
        6 months ago

        Openbox could do most things that Kwin could

        And that was back when both used XOrg to do the heavy lifting.

        Wayfire is used in a lot of minimal desktops. Raspberry PiOS uses it for their new Wayland desktop.