The section that connects to the beach in Gaza was rebuilt nearly two weeks after heavy storms damaged it and abruptly halted what had already been a troubled delivery route.
Let me put it this way- large chunks of The Odyssey are Odysseus being caught in a big storm at sea. So you would think the U.S. military would have heard about something that’s been known since the bronze age.
Exactly, it was (very relatively) cheap and quick. And they figured when, not if, it breaks, it will be again quick to repair. And it is interesting tech that could be useful down the line that they may figure is worth the cost in training alone.
Modular military engineering materials are both obscenely expensive, and temporary. They are meant as a bandaid to quickly solve transportation problems to enable logistics.
Also, being modular, they can be replaced easily and quickly.
If you want a hardy lifetime dock, you’re going to need months to years under ideal circumstances. And then Isreal could “accidentally” blow it up with a “rogue” strike, and there would be no option but to scrap the whole thing. Because most permanent docks aren’t meant to handle military strikes.
But yeah, let’s just ignore that the building constraints around this are just about the worst case imaginable. Let’s just keep whining about how a solution isn’t perfect and therefore worthless like all the other Leftist comments on Lemmy
And then Isreal could “accidentally” blow it up with a “rogue” strike
Yeah maybe they should stop giving rockets to the rogue state that keeps blowing up their shit.
Let’s just keep whining about how a solution isn’t perfect
The only thing this is a solution for is to the problem of “what’s a good way to pretend we’re humanitarians while genociding the people we’re pretending we care about”, so yeah, it’s worthless if you don’t want that to happen.
I don’t know enough about the Mediterranean climate to know if this was a bad idea, but it sounds like they didn’t either
Let me put it this way- large chunks of The Odyssey are Odysseus being caught in a big storm at sea. So you would think the U.S. military would have heard about something that’s been known since the bronze age.
It’s almost like they had to make compromises because their options were limited by materials, time, and access to the site.
It’s almost like Biden should have forced israel to let in aid through the land crossing like the ICJ ruling required israel to do.
Exactly, it was (very relatively) cheap and quick. And they figured when, not if, it breaks, it will be again quick to repair. And it is interesting tech that could be useful down the line that they may figure is worth the cost in training alone.
The piece of shit cost $230 million and lasted 10 days
Modular military engineering materials are both obscenely expensive, and temporary. They are meant as a bandaid to quickly solve transportation problems to enable logistics.
Also, being modular, they can be replaced easily and quickly.
If you want a hardy lifetime dock, you’re going to need months to years under ideal circumstances. And then Isreal could “accidentally” blow it up with a “rogue” strike, and there would be no option but to scrap the whole thing. Because most permanent docks aren’t meant to handle military strikes.
But yeah, let’s just ignore that the building constraints around this are just about the worst case imaginable. Let’s just keep whining about how a solution isn’t perfect and therefore worthless like all the other Leftist comments on Lemmy
They barely delivered any aid. This was a boondoggle.
It’s amazing the military ineptness people excuse.
What’s your solution, then? Overnight peace in the middle east?
I’d say the U.S. not offering Israel any more support until they open the borders to aid would go a long way to solving things.
But apparently that’s going way beyond the pale.
The fuck does someone’s political alignment have to do with this shit?
The tendency to make Perfect the enemy of Good.
It’s a tired theme here on Lemmy, particularly WRT Gaza, and particularly in criticism of Biden’s policy towards Isreal.
Yeah maybe they should stop giving rockets to the rogue state that keeps blowing up their shit.
The only thing this is a solution for is to the problem of “what’s a good way to pretend we’re humanitarians while genociding the people we’re pretending we care about”, so yeah, it’s worthless if you don’t want that to happen.