If you previously preferred browsing old.reddit for its compact and information dense web layout, you should know that this theme can be replicated for Lemmy using monkey scripts.
For more information on installing browser extensions to use scripts linked by this post, checkout:
- https://greasyfork.org
- https://violentmonkey.github.io/
- Recommend given recent context:
- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34830903
I think the rationale is that most people use widescreen monitors nowadays, so if you allow the content part to run across the entire width of the screen, it becomes ugly and hard to read. Therefore the middle section gets a limited or fixed width, which in turn then creates two empty columns to the sides that designers are then tempted to fill up with “useful” stuff.
You can try this yourself: paste a long line of text into a notepad window and maximize the window. It is much harder on your eyes to read and focus on the text than if you resized the window to a more reasonable width where the text gets broken up into several lines.
I’m not against this design paradigm per se, but the content width reduction is often overdone, leading to a squeezed feeling like you say. It can also create problems if you have a habit of not using maximized browser windows, but for example a window tiled to one half of the screen. Some of the better sites work around this by having a reactive design that reduces, collapses or removes the sidebars when the window is narrower than a certain width, but many sites don’t.
I haven’t used maximized windows since the 4:3 CRT days. Another annoyance arises when windows are tiled horizontally. It becomes an exercise in frustration trying to wiggle the window size until responsive design collapses the sidebar.
Ultimately it it seems desktop has become a second class citizen over mobile.