I dont watching much football as I want this season, and I can do mea culpa if Dibu has been amazing this season, but compared to other goalkeepers from past years, I can say a few better then Emi
Courtois, Ederson, Alisson, Stegen, Maignan, Diogo Costa, Neuer, . Atleast, overall, I cannot put Dibu on top5
Courtois isn’t playing this season. Alisson and Neuer are past their prime. I agree with you on Maignan and Ederson but from what I’ve seen of Dibu this season and last (plus the world cup) he is either on their level or really really close to it.
I make you a question. You reply me with a link. What do you expect me to tell you?? Doesnt makes sense. Wow dude. I can give you A LOT of examples of players which won trophies and arent good at all.
That link was backing up the opinion. How about this link? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yashin_Trophy
“the winner is selected by former Ballon d’Or winners since its creation in 2019”
Does that prove anything or do you know better than the elite athletes who have played against these keepers?
I have an opinion about it and dont need an external opinion to build mine. From that point of view, I cant critisize manager options, because they know more than me. I see games and build my opinion. Simple. These vision is completly limited.
you can criticize an opinion without completely discarding it. The opinions of the people who voted for those awards are at least as valid as yours. Tell us why you think different than them.
Oh. So, your opinion is related about winning trophys? I guess I dont need watch games to make an opinion, from that point of view.
Did you watch the world cup? Also have you watched the premier League this year? Emi has been phenomenal.
I dont watching much football as I want this season, and I can do mea culpa if Dibu has been amazing this season, but compared to other goalkeepers from past years, I can say a few better then Emi
Courtois, Ederson, Alisson, Stegen, Maignan, Diogo Costa, Neuer, . Atleast, overall, I cannot put Dibu on top5
Courtois isn’t playing this season. Alisson and Neuer are past their prime. I agree with you on Maignan and Ederson but from what I’ve seen of Dibu this season and last (plus the world cup) he is either on their level or really really close to it.
lemmy.ml moment
I make you a question. You reply me with a link. What do you expect me to tell you?? Doesnt makes sense. Wow dude. I can give you A LOT of examples of players which won trophies and arent good at all.
https://media1.giphy.com/media/JwjBy94VzDd6/200.gif
Nice conversation. Wish you all the best, btw.
That link was backing up the opinion. How about this link? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yashin_Trophy “the winner is selected by former Ballon d’Or winners since its creation in 2019” Does that prove anything or do you know better than the elite athletes who have played against these keepers?
I have an opinion about it and dont need an external opinion to build mine. From that point of view, I cant critisize manager options, because they know more than me. I see games and build my opinion. Simple. These vision is completly limited.
And , for me , trophies dont proof anything
you can criticize an opinion without completely discarding it. The opinions of the people who voted for those awards are at least as valid as yours. Tell us why you think different than them.
I disagree if their opinion is different from mine. If I think player X is better or deserve more credit than player Y, is based on what I see.
I just dont give an excepcional importance on individual trophys, since they are purely based on colective awards.
For example, for me Haaland isnt top3 best players of City squad, despite the goals he scored
No one in this thread brought up trophies for winning competitions. We’re talking about awards for individual performance that were voted on.
And you know why they win individual trophies?because of colective trophies. Thats why Emi wins the golden glove. Because Argentina wins the WC