• persolb
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    1 year ago

    Your response seems to be equivalent to “never defend yourself against someone holding an innocent hostage.”

    To clarify, I’m not sure what response doesn’t result in more innocent people dying.

    I don’t really care about this specific conflict more than any other. And morally I don’t care for the lives of one side more than the other. And morally I don’t care who lived in what cities 100 years ago (note: unless those specific people are involved).

    My confusion seems to be that the ‘right’ response people seem to want to this is no response.

    • SenorBolsa@beehaw.org
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      1 year ago

      Israel definitely is well within their rights to retaliate against Hamas, it would be foolish to claim otherwise. It’s the exact way they are doing it that is the issue, they are behaving nearly as poorly as their enemy. You can’t just tell the world “look at the barbarity of Hamas slaughtering innocent civilians just out there kibbutzing” and then turn around and bomb civilian hospitals, completely disregard rules of engagement around medical aid killing humanitarian volunteers you were aware of, shutting off all power, water and closing food supply to the Gaza strip, and then act like it’s somehow better than that.

      Hamas absolutely sucks and Israel has every right to defend themselves from terrorism, but the Palestinian children buried under rubble didn’t deserve any of this. (Neither did the Israeli citizens who were slaughtered and kidnapped for that matter.)

      Israel has the technology, the troops, and the tactics to be far more precise and surgical in their retaliation, but their response has been punitive and brutal, and seems to almost maximize collateral damage. Of course that’s what Netanyahu and his thugs will all but directly say they want given the opportunity to speak. I do not believe that properly represents the citizens of Israel who are generally much more sympathetic to the people of Palestine.

      Both the citizens of Israel and Palestine have been failed by their leadership. Agree or disagree, at this point, I just had to write that down somewhere. I know people from both Palestine and Israel, wonderful people, all this is heartbreaking.

      War is hell, even if you play by the rules, why make it even worse?

      • persolb
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        6
        ·
        1 year ago

        Thanks. It’s hard for me to judge tactics from video, as I can’t really tell what is accidental collateral damage vs purposeful. The statements by Israeli leadership definitely supports the view that they are purposefully being punitive… which is monstrous.

    • NoIWontPickaName@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      1 year ago

      Idk but bombing innocents doing what you said and trying to evacuate isn’t 1 of the steps.

      Neither is bombing near one of the few border crossings they could use isn’t one either