The university’s hypocrisy became apparent to me and other Palestinian students almost immediately after October 7, 2023. On October 9, students at the Michigan Law School used the public law-open server, an email chain that connects everyone at the law school, to describe Palestinians as “animals” and their Muslim and Arab classmates as “rejoic[ing] in mass murder” and supporting rape. This language was reported to the administration, who took no action.
As the greater Michigan student body started organising and protesting on campus, the university’s discrimination against marginalised students became even more apparent. It repeatedly sent campus police to disperse our protests and sit-ins, with students being physically assaulted, pepper-sprayed and arrested, while hijabs of female students were ripped off.
It also ramped up surveillance. Police presence and the number of surveillance cameras around the Arab lounge on campus noticeably increased.
The administration never issued any apology for nor condemnation of the extreme acts of police violence against students who were protesting a genocide that the university funds.
Yes, absolutely true. US universities have become heavily bureaucratized at the same time they became financialized - defunded by states and dependent on endowments (that they invest), real estate schemes (also drawing from private donors), and finance-backed tuition. Public universities have PR teams, marketing teams, and police departments.
Yup. Bright side (were the courts not captured by the right) in theory public universities cannot privilege Jewish Semites above Arab Semites, or anyone else. Future classes at the elite universities the court is composed of will hand wring at seminars about their decisions about this in retrospect unless Netanyahu realizes full Man In The High Castle domination.
Re: handwringing, I’ll give that a maybe. Law students that study the SC end up going down two paths:
The ones that realize it’s just a political organ like the other branches with a facade of “calling balls and strikes” and decide to think the whole thing should be ridiculed and abolished.
Same as 1 but they sell the facade because they want to clerk for a justice or other high level judge.
I think the most likely impact on them will be, “throw it on the pile”!