I played Cat in the Box today for the first time, and while I grew up on trick takers, and have nearly all the other mentioned suggestions on this post I just did not like this one. I need to get at least 10-15 plays before I make a final thought on it, but it is in the bottom for me.
For games I know I will play a ton, I usually get Ryker Sleeves https://www.rykergames.com/ since I love the dimpled backs which makes shuffles really easy. For nearly everything else, and especially hard to find size then I use Swan Panasia sleeves. https://www.swanpanasiasleeves.com/