The Chinese Room and Masking

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room

It’s a pretty cool thought experiment about a hypothetical person locked in a room. In the room they have books on Chinese words, phrases, and grammar. They receive a sheet of paper with Chinese written on it and send out a written response using the books as reference. The person inside the room doesn’t know what they’re writing and the outside person doesn’t know that they don’t understand Chinese.

It really speaks to me in how I navigate a lot of social connections without knowing why. I receive an input, and while I’m not sure why, I’m conditioned to respond in a specific way.

The thought experiment reminds me of masking and how it’s hard to explain to someone you don’t understand. Because of their perception of your actions/words, they assume you understand the fundamental idea.

When I keep up the mask, I know that it’s easier to do things in certain ways and hide evidence of misunderstanding. I think that’s where a level of isolation happens for me. It’s like I’m locked in a room away from people and my communication is filtered through a system I don’t understand at all.

I dunno, I was just thinking about thought experiments in general and how neurodiversity can show up.

Does anybody else have thoughts on the Chinese Room or other thought experiments in relation to a neurodiverse experience?

Rules

1.) ableist language=post or comment will probably get removed (enforced case by case, some comments will be removed and restored due to complex situations). repeated use of ableist language=banned from comm and possibly site depending on severity. properly tagged posts with CW can use them for the purposes of discussing them

2.) always assume good faith when dealing with a fellow nd comrade especially due to lack of social awareness being a common symptom of neurodivergence

2.5) right to disengage is rigidly enforced. violations will get you purged from the comm. see rule 3 for explanation on appeals

3.) no talking over nd comrades about things you haven’t personally experienced as a neurotypical chapo, you will be purged. If you’re ND it is absolutely fine to give your own perspective if it conflicts with another’s, but do so with empathy and the intention to learn about each other, not prove who’s experience is valid. Appeal process is like appealing in user union but you dm the nd comrade you talked over with your appeal (so make it a good one) and then dm the mods with screenshot proof that you resolved it. fake screenies will get you banned from the site, we will confirm with the comrade you dm’d.

3.5) everyone has their own lived experiences, and to invalidate them is to post cringe. comments will be removed on a case by case basis depending on determined level of awareness and faith

4.) Interest Policing will not be tolerated in any form. Support your comrades in their joy!

Further rules to be added/ rules to be changed based on community input

RULES NOTE: For this community more than most we understand that the clarity and understandability of these rules is very important for allowing folks to feel comfortable, to that end please don’t be afraid to be outspoken about amendments and addendums to these rules, as well as any we may have missed

xXthrowawayXx [none/use name]@hexbear.net English

18·

11 months ago

If that sounds compelling, consider that the Chinese room thought experiment was created to argue against machine learning.

Not only does it represent an intuitive way to understand how machine learning is fake, but how masking isn’t going to change the way you handle social interactions or help you develop skills.