- cross-posted to:
- games@sh.itjust.works
- cross-posted to:
- games@sh.itjust.works
You must log in or register to comment.
You get what you fucking deserve.
There’s only one award it could win: Most Disappointing Game of the Year
Anyone who had built up their expectations hadn’t been paying attention.
Yeah, seems fitting.
A lot of good games came out this year. Starfield wasn’t up to muster.
I feel like I can commend them on the launch being significantly less buggy than other titles in prior years (big yikes to FO76). Other than that, the game was pretty bland. I got bored of it rather than annoyed with it. Usually a Bethesda game will annoy me about 10-15 hours in with some weird game-breaking bug, but I played probably about 50 hours of Starfield before just getting bored of the same spacers in the same tunnels strung together by quick travel menus.
The big thing that was missing for me was culture. And it made me appreciate Cyberpunk 2077 that much more. There are people everywhere in Starfield, but the only real differences between them are that they’re generic American with cowboy hat versus generic American with business-casual clothes versus generic American with streetpunk clothes stood under neon lights. There’s no difference in how people talk. Even the people who’d never interacted with anyone outside of their own community before - who thought they were the last remaining humans - felt the same. There are people everywhere but no real personality.
Versus Cyberpunk 2077, where CDPR created so much culture. There are hours and hours’ worth of original songs for the game. There are adverts everywhere that really capture the feeling of the world. People from different parts of the city and different groups have their own dialects. There’s so much slang invented for the game. Even the architecture and design of the city tells stories. Sure, the average NPC has no real personality or routine on an individual level, but the world and culture are so well fleshed out. Starfield has none of that.
I also did seem to get hit with quite a few game-breaking bugs in Starfield. I couldn’t progress the temple questline - they gave no no powers and the quest didn’t advance properly. I had some terrible bugs regarding ship ownership that resulted in me having to load a save from 20 hours previous. It was just a disaster for me, and really killed any enjoyment I may have been getting from the game.
To be completely fair, a lot of the world already existed with the cyberpunk ttrpg, but this is an incredible point.
I’m starting to become disturbed by how amazingly well starfield makes everyone think about what exactly makes other games feel amazing. I wouldn’t have even considered the culture present in cyberpunk, because it feels so real and natural.
Starfield is like, the hazy silhouette of a real civilisation. There are buildings and people in them, and sometimes the people go to different buildings. That’s a perfect description of the real world right? 100% immersion
Definitely. I enjoyed it myself, but Tears unseated Ocarina of Time as my favorite Zelda game. There’s no question that there was much better options this year to me.
What about it was worthy of an award? Having a big launch doesn’t count for anything and all I’ve heard aside of that is disappointment.
Not sure why this article was even written.
I just recently started playing and as a diehard Elder Scrolls/Fallout fan the game is the worst Copy+Paste I’ve seen!
Obsidian made the same game in 2019 and called it The Outer Worlds. Bethesda took their game added some more to it and released it as Starfield. Neon City is literally the same place as Groundbreaker.
The space mechanics are an absolute joke considering what No Man’s Sky gave us in recent years.
I guess the point of my removed little comment is that I expected so much more and was thoroughly underwhelmed.
The bar for the next Elder Scrolls/Fallout is so low for me at this point, that I have zero expectation of even playing them
no mans sky is a space sim. starfield is an rpg. its like saying chess sucks because candyland exists
It tries to do both and does neither well.
no mans sky?
Did anyone actually think this game was a contender? I stopped playing after like 10 hours because it felt like I was doing chores.
Me too. It felt like Skyrim or Fallout but in another setting with better graphics. Glad I didn’t pay the full prize for it because I have Game Pass
deleted by creator
Don’t you know that if you didn’t like the game, it’s dumb systems, it’s dull gameplay, it’s utter lack of vision and ambition, and it’s rote-to-cringe setting then that means you are just a Sony Pony, even if you play on PC?
Starfield was hot garbage. I want my time and money back.
You know what WAS robbed? Age of Wonders 4. The entire strategy category is nothing but objectively bad to objectively mid games, with a bizarrely disproportionate Nintendo representation… and yet one of the best grand strategy games in decades wasn’t even nominated…? How does that happen?
Points at people who pre-ordered…
Ha! Ha!
I preordered and I am close to 300 hours of playtime.
Idk what you get from the thought that people dont enjoy the game but I can tell you for all its shortcomings I still have a lot of fun with Starfield.
Nominated for one thing: Best RPG, in which it is probably the worst one there.
I was surprised at the backlash the GA got for that. Worst take was someone claiming that they are afraid of nominate a “new” IP
Is it really that unbelievable to people that Starfield is just not that good in comparison to many other games that came out this year?
