I am currently running an RPI 4b+ for a home server.

I was able to obtain a small PC with an i5 4690 in it. It has a 300W Be Quite! PSU and a Gigabyte GA-H97M MOBO. I would like to move my stuff from the RPI to this machine, as it has much more slots for HDDs.

For the sake of argument lets imagine I plug 4x4TB HDDs and 1 500mb SSD for the OS and run an Ubuntu LTS on it.

How much average electricity usage am I facing per month in kW/h? How much more would it be compared to the RPI which now has an external 1 TB HDD attached to it over USB?

Thanks a lot!

  • djgizmo@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    I5 4690 idle, with all drives spinning (no read/write) at 60-70watts constant. Maybe a little less. I have a i7 4770s and it’s around 75watts idle with 8 drives, half spun down most of the time. Which is roughly 54 kWH.

  • viper2035@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    I optimized a i5 4590 with 16 GB RAM and two 14 TB Seagate drives for power consumption. With spin down the minimum I was able to reach was around 26 W. Way to high for me. I switch to an i3 8100 system and this idles around 10W. At me region I have the invested money back after around 1 year.

  • mrln_bllmnn@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    I run various haswell i5 hosts, one of them has 84 watts tdp.

    i5 4460, 4x 4GB, 1x sata ssd, 2x dual port gigabit lan pcie card. Whole thing draws < 50 watts with 10 % cpu load.

  • mandonovski@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    I have similar machine, i5 4670, 32GB of RAM, 2 ssd drives, consumption is 40-50 Watts.

  • IlTossico@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    Going for an OS without a UI, no monitor mouse and keyboard. All HDDs idling, I would say less than 20W.

    HDDs generally idle at 0,3W, spinning and writing/reading around 6W and from idle to spinning around 12W for a peak.

    • nataku411@alien.topBEnglish
      1·
      10 months ago

      I just nabbed an amazing deal on eBay, a Dell Precision 3420 with a Xeon e3 1270v6 for $90. Gonna make it a headless server and hoping to get it idling around 30-50 watts. For comparison my gaming rig idles at a whopping 90-120w.

      • IlTossico@alien.topBEnglish
        1·
        10 months ago

        With xeon it is a bit more difficult to have lower power consumption, they aren’t made with power consumption in mind but performance 24/7. But 30/40W I think it’s likely possible. L variant can idle a bit lower but not as good as desktop CPU.

        The problem with gaming PCs is that generally they have a lot of RGB, fans and VRM, mine too idle around 80W, even if I tweak it very well, and fun fact I can lower my 9900k to 6W and my 2080 is around 12W, but I’ve 6 fans, RGB on the motherboard and ram, I’ve 32gb of ram too, and my motherboard have tons of VRM for good OC. Not only, I’ve a 850W PSU so the efficiency curve is around 450W, at 60W load the PSU takes 80W from the grid, and generally efficiency is around 80%.

        • nataku411@alien.topBEnglish
          1·
          10 months ago

          Yeah it’s crazy how it all stacks up. Back when I had all my RGB on, 2x pumps, 11 fans, with the monitors on my power draw at idle was almost 200w. Power prices here aren’t great so running my gaming pc 24/7 costs me almost $100 by itself each month. Planning on cutting that down greatly with this new server.

          • IlTossico@alien.topBEnglish
            1·
            10 months ago

            I have my gaming setup almost always on, like 12 hours a day, in fact I was thinking about getting another Lenovo Tiny and doing a hackintosh, and use it for general purpose like watching anime and browsing, but would be a pain having to share all 3 monitors, keyboard and mouse with two system. So, amen, when I build my next gaming PC, I would remove all RGB and go MITX.

  • unevoljitelj@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    Probably around 80w, maybe 90. But lets say 80. 802430=57kilowats a month… Rpi with hdd wont draw more then 15w, maybe 10-12w. So thats about 8-10kilwats a month. So basicaly about 6 times more electricity.

  • jonstarks@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    I have a unraid server using a 7700k with 4x 4TB drives, 10G NIC, with 3 docker containers running pulls ~43watts 24x7. My electric is about $0.14 so about $4.40/month.

  • marc45ca@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    find an online calculator used for determining a UPS size (google will help).

    That will give you an indication on how power the system will use.

    then calculate based on your electricity price (thin there are online calculators that will do that as well).

  • InfaSyn@alien.topBEnglish
    1·
    10 months ago

    Would guestimate the PC (with no GPU) to pull maybe 100w assuming an average load of 20 ish percent. - 40 of this would come from drives (about 10w each).

    This would be about 2.4kwh/day or in the UK, around £0.70 on a cheap tariff (or £255 a year). Obviously these figures vary massively depending on power cost per kwh in your region