Hi Self Hosting Lemmings!

I’m looking to upgrade the RAM in my 3-node proxmox cluster and could use some advice. I have 3 HP ProDesk 600 G3 Mini PCs that claim to support up to 32GB of RAM. However, I would really like to upgrade to 2x32GB for 64GB total.

Is it possible to run with more RAM than the recommended amount? If so, are there any problems I might run into? Any insight is greatly appreciated, thanks!

  • Godort@lemm.ee
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    43
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    There are a few things that determine the amount of RAM your PC can handle.

    Simplest is the amount of slots on the Mobo. It’s hard to put extra RAM into a machine if there is nowhere to plug it in.

    Next is the motherboard limitation. This is mostly based on the type of RAM it takes. DDR4 has a maximum size of 64GB per DIMM and DDR5 maxes out at 512GB per DIMM

    Finally and most crucially is the CPU. CPUs have onboard memory controllers these days and they can only handle the amount of RAM that they can address. This value changes from CPU to CPU so you’ll want to check the specs for the model you have.

    If you go over the supported amount, the PC will likely just fail to POST and never boot. If it does boot it will just ignore the extra RAM and never actually use it.

    • Biscoot@thelemmy.clubOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      15
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      This is good comprehensive advice that allowed me to do more of my own fact checking against my hardware. Looks like my hardware should support 64GB RAM just fine, with the caveat that my CPU will only be able to run the RAM at max of 2400Mhz. But I’m ok with the speed limitation, since I’m after the capacity. Cheers!