• 10A@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    arrow-down
    2
    ·
    1 year ago

    The flag

    Gotcha. The flag’s not a false idol at all. Not sure where you live, but I’m in a fairly Christian conservative area, and it’s commonplace to see “kneel for the cross, stand for the flag” signs. Nobody worships the flag. It’s just a uniting symbol of our neighbors across the nation. When we say “love your neighbor”, the flag is the imagery that comes to mind for me. It’s not an idol at all, just a symbol of our fellow Americans, who we strive to love.

    You don’t have to hate somebody to do something hateful towards them or say something hateful. Hate isn’t always intentional.

    What a peculiar claim. Hatred is a feeling. I know what’s in my heart. You don’t. You can misinterpret my words, but you can’t rightfully ascribe feelings to my heart which I don’t feel.

    • PizzaMan@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      The flag’s not a false idol at all. Not sure where you live, but I’m in a fairly Christian conservative area, and it’s commonplace to see “kneel for the cross, stand for the flag” signs.

      That fits the bill:

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Idolatry

      Nobody worships the flag.

      They absolutely do, and you’ve done quite a bit of it yourself from what I have read from you. You treat is as a moral failure for not treating the flag with the utmost respect, and that is a form of worship.

      What a peculiar claim. Hatred is a feeling. I know what’s in my heart. You don’t. You can misinterpret my words, but you can’t rightfully ascribe feelings to my heart which I don’t feel.

      Hate can be a feeling, but it isn’t always a feeling. Hatred can be a cold unfeeling action, or speech. Granted, I think if this part of the conversation continues any further then it will devolve into semantics.

      • 10A@kbin.social
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        1 year ago

        Semantics matter! So many of our disagreements are rooted in our using different definitions, and talking past each other, thinking the other side is crazy because we’re misinterpreting each other’s words.

        You don’t have to convince me to change my personal definition of anything. But by defining yours, as you have, I can understand where you’re coming from. The fact that I don’t consider it hatred doesn’t much matter.

        So @thepixelfox’s point (and I suppose your point too) that I am cold and unfeeling towards foreigners who break into the US illegally is absolutely correct. Again I want to emphasize that I don’t hate these people emotionally. But I don’t think they deserve an ounce of our sympathy either. They’re not our neighbors; they’re hostile invaders.

        You treat is as a moral failure for not treating the flag with the utmost respect, and that is a form of worship.

        I’d treat it as a moral failure to disrespect a neighbor, and the flag symbolizes our neighbors. Moreover, I believe the US is one nation under God, and that concept is represented in our flag.

        Listen, I’m a sinner, and I don’t pretend to be even slightly perfect. There is so much I deserve to be judged for, and I’ll accept that judgment when the day comes. But one of the few sins I’m not guilty of, to the best of my knowledge, is idolatry.

        And in my experience, it’s uncommon for others to worship the flag either. Treating it with respect out of respect for our neighbors and our nation is wholly different from worshiping it.

        • PizzaMan@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          5
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          1 year ago

          They’re not our neighbors; they’re hostile invaders.

          They aren’t hostile though. They commit crimes at a lower rate than the general population. And they aren’t moving here out of malice, they are doing so to have better lives.

          I’d treat it as a moral failure to disrespect a neighbor, and the flag symbolizes our neighbors.

          Not everyone sees the flag that way. A lot of people see it in a negative light for a lot of different reasons. But that’s it’s own tangent.

          My point is, regardless of what the flag represents, it is a symbol/image (idol) other than god that is worshiped.

          it’s uncommon for others to worship the flag either

          When Kaepernick kneeled instead of standing for the flag/anthem, people hated his guts ultimately because he wasn’t worshiping it, and worshiping it is often seen as the default. I won’t speak to how common it is, but it is definitely common enough to be noticeable. Another good example is how school children worship the flag every day with the pledge of allegiance.

          • 10A@kbin.social
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            2
            arrow-down
            3
            ·
            1 year ago

            Once somebody becomes an illegal, everything they do is inherently illegal until they retreat from American soil. How is it possible for them to be less illegal than a bona fide American when their entire state of being, and everything they do, is inherently illegal? It seems like you’re telling me I’d see that they’re actually good citizens if only I’d ignore the facts that they’re neither good nor citizens.

            Anyone who has any kind of negative association with the American flag needs to get out of the US, ASAP, and I do support deportation for them. But you’re right, that’s it’s own tangent.

            With regard to your position on idolatry, I do understand your viewpoint, and I don’t defend idolatry. Of all the various reasons one might refuse to salute the flag, I think a fear of idolatry is perhaps the only one I’d consider valid. I get why you wouldn’t want to touch it with a ten-foot pole. I only ask that you trust me when I say I don’t worship the flag.

            In my personal life, whenever I pledge my allegiance to the flag (which happens at least once per week), it’s always preceded by a prayer. That’s the same way it always was for school children too until SCOTUS banned it in '62. I believe that was a mistake, and saying the pledge without an opening prayer can certainly leave the wrong impression.

            • PizzaMan@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              4
              arrow-down
              1
              ·
              1 year ago

              Once somebody becomes an illegal, everything they do is inherently illegal until they retreat from American soil. How is it possible for them to be less illegal than a bona fide American when their entire state of being, and everything they do, is inherently illegal?

              That’s not how the legal system treats it. Being in the country illegal is counted as one crime.

              Anyone who has any kind of negative association with the American flag needs to get out of the US, ASAP, and I do support deportation for them.

              The government deporting people based on political opinions like this is antithetical to the founding principles of our nation, and is un-american. It’s also a violation of the first amendment.

              I only ask that you trust me when I say I don’t worship the flag.

              I’m sorry but I can’t trust that when you treat people who don’t respect the flag as a moral failures.

              saying the pledge without an opening prayer can certainly leave the wrong impression.

              Opening prayer and the allegiance itself leaves the wrong impression. People should not be forced to partake in another’s religion, nor should they be forced to worship the flag/the country.

              • 10A@kbin.social
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                arrow-down
                2
                ·
                1 year ago

                That’s not how the legal system treats it.

                I’m aware. The Left has a voice in the legal system, and as a result it’s soft on crime, and especially crime related to this discussion. But in truth, an illegal immigrant cannot even brush his teeth legally if he does so on American soil.

                The government deporting people based on political opinions like this is antithetical to the founding principles of our nation, and is un-american.

                “Love it or leave it” is a traditionally American patriotic slogan. It’s simple but true, and it applies to all things in life, not just the country. But when it comes to the country, it should be policy. I don’t favor kicking out any legitimate citizen who recognizes this is the best country in the world, and would gladly fight and die to defend it. But for the leftists who hate America and want to change it to become more like some other country, they really need to pack up and move to that other country. There’s nothing un-American about saying Americans ought to be American at heart.

                It’s also a violation of the first amendment.

                Not really, because I wouldn’t want to take away anyone’s right to freely express their position, even if that means criticizing America. They have every right to cuss up a storm while they spew their hatred of everything American, while I help them pack, and escort them to the airport.

                I’m sorry but I can’t trust that when you treat people who don’t respect the flag as a moral failures.

                That fact makes you certain I worship the flag? That doesn’t make any sense. I stand up for my neighbors, and by extension my country, and by extension the cloth that symbolizes it. That’s not worship. That’s just following what Jesus said is the second most important commandment.

                Opening prayer and the allegiance itself leaves the wrong impression. People should not be forced to partake in another’s religion, nor should they be forced to worship the flag/the country.

                It’s worthwhile to look at the background of the '62 ban on school prayer. Protestants read from the KJV, and Catholics didn’t like the KJV. The argument was all about which translation to use in public schools. SCOTUS decided that the only way to solve the problem was to choose no Bible at all.

                It’s also worthwhile to consider the Crusades, which were successful by some measures, but are also widely criticized for valid reasons. One of those reasons is that it’s truly impossible to force anyone to believe in a religion if they don’t want to. And it’s counterproductive to try.

                So I agree that people shouldn’t be forced to partake in religious practices against their will. But that just means we should leave Protestant vs Catholic fights to other forums, and prayers in public forums like schools should be generic. Whatever religion Americans hold, we can safely assume it’s some form of Christianity, with a slim possibility of Judaism in some places.

                When it comes to satanists, atheists, or anyone else who rejects the God for which America was founded, they should be given a genuine chance to repent and accept God before being politely deported.

                And as for being “forced to worship the flag/the country”, again, the pledge of allegiance just says “I promise to love my neighbor.” If someone can’t pledge to do that, you’ve got to wonder why they live here.

                • PizzaMan@lemmy.world
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  3
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  1 year ago

                  But in truth, an illegal immigrant cannot even brush his teeth legally if he does so on American soil.

                  That’s not true. I hate to repeat myself, but that’s not how the judicial branch treats it. To treat brushing your teeth in this manner to be illegal would be a violation of the 5th amendment of the constitution, because that would be double jeopardy. And this isn’t a thing the left is responsible for, because the left did not write the constitution.

                  “Love it or leave it” is a traditionally American patriotic slogan.

                  And it’s one that is a great disservice to this country.

                  But for the leftists who hate America and want to change it to become more like some other country, they really need to pack up and move to that other country.

                  I would if I could. But that costs thousands of dollars, and that’s assuming you find a good country that will take you in at all. Your expectation for people to up and move is unrealistic given the reality that it isn’t possible for a third to half of Americans to immigrate to Europe.

                  You’re suggesting upwards of 100 million people up and move to another country. That isn’t realistic, nor is it an effective solution to the problem.

                  The United States needs to be able to change instead of just kicking people out, and that’s why the founding fathers specifically built our country to be able to accommodate change.

                  There’s nothing un-American about saying Americans ought to be American at heart.

                  That’s not what you said though:

                  “Anyone who has any kind of negative association with the American flag needs to get out of the US, ASAP, and I do support deportation for them.”

                  Deporting american citizens because they disagree with you is un-american. And it’s also a violation of the first amendment.

                  Not really, because I wouldn’t want to take away anyone’s right to freely express their position, even if that means criticizing America. They have every right to cuss up a storm while they spew their hatred of everything American, while I help them pack, and escort them to the airport.

                  The government forcing people out of the country because of their expressed opinion/position is a direct violation of the first amendment. The government CANNOT punish people for their opinions, and deporting them is a form of punishment.

                  That fact makes you certain I worship the flag? That doesn’t make any sense. I stand up for my neighbors, and by extension my country, and by extension the cloth that symbolizes it. That’s not worship. That’s just following what Jesus said is the second most important commandment.

                  If you said the same thing about Jesus as you did the flag I would think the same about you worshiping Jesus.

                  But that just means we should leave Protestant vs Catholic fights to other forums, and prayers in public forums like schools should be generic.

                  Prayer in schools even if generic is still a form of forcing religion upon others.

                  When it comes to satanists, atheists, or anyone else who rejects the God for which America was founded, they should be given a genuine chance to repent and accept God before being politely deported.

                  This is the same un-american violation of the first amendment as above.

                  the pledge of allegiance just says “I promise to love my neighbor.”

                  That’s not at all what it says.

                  • “I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all”
                  • 10A@kbin.social
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    2
                    arrow-down
                    2
                    ·
                    1 year ago

                    double jeopardy

                    I acquiesce this is technically correct. I didn’t really mean it like that, exactly, but it’s useless to belabor the point because we’re beating a dead horse.

                    I would if I could. But that costs thousands of dollars,

                    Interesting. Where would you move, out of curiosity?

                    At times in the past I’ve mulled over starting a non-profit for the purpose of funding politically-oriented moves like this, where funds are granted to people of all political persuasions to relocate to a more politically appropriate place, and where funds are donated by people wanting to help accelerate that sorting process.

                    I wouldn’t really start that non-profit, because ultimately it would distract from legitimately good charities, but it does cross my mind now and then.

                    and that’s assuming you find a good country that will take you in at all.

                    Yes, well this is also one of the reasons why all of my calls for deportation are unrealistic.

                    Deporting american citizens because they disagree with you is un-american. And it’s also a violation of the first amendment.

                    Agreed, but disagreeing with me is not the problem. I enjoy open disagreement, as I’m mostly enjoying this conversation with you. We can learn from engaging with people of differing perspectives.

                    When you talk about people who harbor a negative association with the American flag, though, that’s far beyond a disagreement. You’re talking about domestic terrorists there. They’re absolutely not American at heart, so why would we allow them to live here? These are people who are likely to commit mass murder at the drop of a hat. I imagine there’s probably less than a dozen such people nationwide.

                    Prayer in schools even if generic is still a form of forcing religion upon others.

                    Not whatsoever. There are a zillion denominations and factions of Christianity, and they’re all welcome here, no matter how zany they are. Moreover, prayer is an open dialog with God, so almost all Christian prayers are fairly applicable to Jews and Muslims too, if they overlook a few words. That’s the broadest acceptable spectrum of every religion in America. Bear in mind that we have the freedom of religion, not freedom from it.

                    That’s not at all what [the Pledge] says.

                    You’re being overly literal. I know what the words to the Pledge are, thank you. I just recited it earlier today in church. What I meant was that it ultimately tells us to love our neighbors. That’s the root meaning behind it.