• Bilbo Baggins@hobbit.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    11 months ago

    I feel like posting art here should have to include some sort of background or explanation. I would like to know how I’m supposed to interpret this image.

    FWIW, art that gets posted to !hobbit_art@hobbit.world is supposed to explain what’s going on if possible. I like art, but I think art has to include background or it’s just a pretty picture.

    • quinacridoneOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      11 months ago

      I don’t think there’s anything wrong with art being ‘just a pretty picture’, there is plenty of artwork that has powerful meaning attached to it, for example ‘Guernica’ by Picasso- it’s striking, very large, has a strong anti war message and is loaded with symbolism…I wouldn’t want it on my wall though (even if I could get it to fit)

      I like abstracts mainly because I love colour (I think it may be an autistic thing, as I don’t like portraits or images where humans appear, but I can still appreciate the technical skill involved)

      For me, an image like this is visually bathing in colour, it’s very stimulating or it can be soothing depending on the colour used. I like the patterns and how they repeat, also how they appear to tumble down the canvas/paper, there’s an energy in the composition and also in the marks made by the brush/pastel/pen.

      The community you link has in the sidebar-

      ‘It is not required, but if you know, please talk a bit about the scene in the image. What’s going on? Who is in it? Why is it happening? Do you like it? Why?’

      possibly to encourage engagement and discussion, which is a nice touch, I think it also helps that all the images are illustrating scenes from Tolkien literature, who was rather good (an understatement) at writing and world building. I think that Tolkein produced enough detailed content to be discussed and analysed for some time

      I think ultimately, even if this piece of art is not to your taste or you don’t understand the meaning (if there is any meaning to it), has got us both talking about it, which I think is a good thing, and possibly the whole point of art in the first place?

      :)

      • Bilbo Baggins@hobbit.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        11 months ago

        I wasn’t complaining about the art. I’ve seen random looking pictures that turned out to have explanations. I remember one gallery where it was just a bunch of rectangles. Someone explained that it was showing how you can be distracted from some details by others and then pointed out shapes I hadn’t seen because the colors of the rectangles pulled my attention. I found that interesting, but would not have gotten it without explanation.

        I just think the forum would be more engaging if artwork was posted with explanations if there is one. Maybe this image is just some pleasing shapes, but it would not surprise me if there was a story.