I read Irredeemable and Incorruptible by Mark Waid recently. Felt largely the same about both: cool premise, but the execution really takes a nosedive on the last 40% of the book. Apparently Waid had a falling out with the publisher so he rushed to the finish which definitely tracks, as plotlines surface and fall away in an odd manner.

I still think they’re worth a read if you’re interested in a “Superman but bad” scenario that’s not injustice