Are monsters inherently malicious to humans? Are they “unnatural” in some way (undead, extradimensional etc)? Or are monsters just more dangerous and powerful animals?
Are monsters inherently malicious to humans? Are they “unnatural” in some way (undead, extradimensional etc)? Or are monsters just more dangerous and powerful animals?
It depends. A monster can be any kind of being which is perceived as dangerous and malicious. They might even be a culture-bearing species. I’d consider the distinction between “monster” and “not monster” to be one of perception. Whether something is considered a monster within a world might depend on many factors like location and even social circle.
Let’s say we have a pseudo-medieval fantasy world. Humans have settled all over the place but there’s also a forest-dwelling race that’s extremely protective of its territory. Let’s say they look like overgrown bodybuilder gorillas; very imposing. Unlike humans those gorilla people don’t care about spreading out; they just have one specific woodland area that they claim as their own. While they do have a culture, they don’t care much for things like permanent structures or settlements. They also don’t like rhetorics and neither send nor receive diplomats. They don’t care much for the outside world, especially for things like cultural exchange or trade goods. They especially don’t like unannounced large groups of people.
Traders all over the continent consider them inherently malicious beings who will slaughter anyone who passes anywhere near their territory. (This typically happens when a caravan is behind schedule and decides to cut through gorilla territory.) You can’t make deals with them; they just want to kill you. Any trader will probably consider them to be monsters and most places that aren’t near their territory will do so even more because they only hear about them from the traders.
The areas adjoining their territory might have a different view. There are villages near the border and the people in those villages know that the gorilla people are perfectly friendly as long as you respect their territory. They’ll even let you go in there as long as you behave yourself and respect their authority. Perhaps they even barter goods and simple services. The villagers are convinced that the gorilla people are decent people who just happen to have their own way of life.
The nobles of the adjoining areas, however, consider them thoroughly savage because they don’t have a head of state or any kind of discernible court, have no temples and don’t follow any officially recognized religion, don’t tolerate diplomatic missions, won’t enter into trade deals or free passage treaties… The list goes on. These animals won’t even let traders pass through their territory unannounced as if they didn’t care about the long-distance trade economy at all.
Now, are the gorilla people monsters? It depends on who you ask.