I frequently find this, for some reason kbin.social comments aren’t federating properly. When they reply to my comment thread I am unable to reply to them, and when I log into kbin.social directly and post there my comment doesn’t show up on lemm.ee for some time at all.

Edit: A good fix is to apply a language to your comment, eg English. This should allow your comment to post. However it seems like there is still some issue with comments federating across after that - your comment might appear on kbin, but you might not get their replies again.

  • TWeaK@lemm.eeOPEnglish
    2·
    1 year ago

    That said, just to clarify, when you say you’re “unable to reply to them” do you mean because their comment doesn’t show up on your side, or because you get some kind of error or other weird behaviour when you try to reply?

    Their comment is there (at least some of them are) but I cannot reply. My comment doesn’t enter in, I just get a spinning wheel, with the text box effectively switched to Preview mode. I don’t think it even times out, it just keeps spinning until I close the page or hit Cancel.

    If I then log in directly to kbin I can reply to them there (and I also sometimes see other kbin comments that aren’t on lemm.ee), however back at lemm.ee my new comment isn’t there. I haven’t gone back to check any of these replies later, I imagine they show up on lemm.ee eventually, but have no idea how long that takes.

    • thegiddystitcher@lemm.eeEnglish
      3·
      1 year ago

      Next time the spinny wheel thing happens, try selecting a comment language from the dropdown. I’ve noticed that sometimes (especially when replying to an external thing from Kbin or Mastodon, but also sometimes from Lemmy so god knows) it won’t let me post without explicitly setting the language.

      Very much a workaround rather than a fix but it might be easier for you than logging over. Assuming it works, of course, and your problem isn’t something totally different!

      • TWeaK@lemm.eeOPEnglish
        2·
        1 year ago

        Thanks for the tip! I’ll give it a go next time I come across the issue, then update here.

      • TWeaK@lemm.eeOPEnglish
        2·
        1 year ago

        Eyup, the language thing worked!

        However I don’t think that’s the whole story. My kbin reply from 2 days ago still isn’t on lemm.ee, my mentions from kbin didn’t alert me in lemm.ee, and while I was able to use the language setting to post a reply, and that reply appeared on kbin, my subsequent reply from kbin did not come back to lemm.ee.

        So while you might be able to get your post out, you probably won’t know if they reply to you.

        It kind of feels like we’re giving them our federated content, but they’re not reliably giving us theirs. However our admin is on it!

        • thegiddystitcher@lemm.eeEnglish
          2·
          1 year ago

          Yeah that checks out. Like I said before the federation issues are definitely still a thing and it does seem to be worse when you’re trying to post cross-platform. Honestly not sure if mentions are even supposed to work, I know for example on Lemmy I can’t DM a Kbin user (even though it looks like we can, but tested with my husband’s Kbin account and apparently DMs to them just disappear into the ether? 🤷‍♀️) so it’s possible we also can’t mention each other. I have no idea though, just guesses!

          I definitely do not envy the devs on either side with all of this work still to do to get both softwares stable, but especially feel for Ernest! Kbin was so new when the influx started, I can’t even imagine the stress. Think I read that he has a lot of contributors helping out now though so at least it’s not just him on his own trying to keep all the plates spinning.

          We’ll get there, I’m sure!