So the major aspect affecting pricing in the last 4 years are paper costs and COVID. Not sure how much Tariffs affected anything.
Here is a rundown of pricing changes I have seen over the years:
Special notes: Isle of Cats never increased in price, always at $50, and even more notable because you get a lot of weight and bits for $50, where I would have seen any other company likely charge $60 for it. Gloomhaven Jaws of the Lion is also at a staggering $50 SRP the whole time!! (How much money did Target give Isaac?)
Asmodee: two major price hikes, one in 2019 and another around 2021-2022. Dice Forge went from $39.99 to a whopping $54.99. Most of their other games went up from $40 to $45 and their $50 to $60. Production hasn’t changed but sales wise I feel like those games have dipped a little on sales.
StoneMeier: Wingspan being around $50-$55 on its first print run now at $65. Scythe went from $80-90. This is the usual with nearly all companies, but Wingspan still flies off the shelves and still one of our top sellers.
Pokemon: You think the Pokemon Company would have jacked up their costs during the Logan Paul inflation demand, but only Jan 2023 did Pokemon increase their SRPs.
HABA Games, Renegade, Arcane Tinmen, Red Raven Games, Rio Grande, etc: Most of these companies increased products by around $5, this seems to be the norm. These mainly occured around early 2021
Play monster Games: I got an email saying US Freight costs increased 300% for them, however they sell cheaper products like Five Crowns so I haven’t noticed how their SRPs increased, maybe a dollar or two.
Games Workshop: so many price changes it was hard to keep track, as I imagine you have to add whatever was happening with the EU might have also affected costs among everything else in the US, or just GW being GW as usual.
Grandpa Beck Games: the usual $1-$2 price hikes for small card games, but I just want to point them out because it was the only email that felt like an actual human being typed it all up instead of using some template like everyone else.
**Wizards of the Coast. There were a tiny bit later in increasing prices around 2022, but I imagine they make so much profit margin selling a piece of cardboard it likely didn’t matter. New D&D books however will start increasing in price next month.
Unfortunately I am only aware of MSRP prices, not secondary market prices. But eBay seems to do something clever where final purchases are hidden so it appears you don’t really know what the value of something is unless you personally have your offer accepted from the seller.
To me that sounds like a great way to ensure prices are high but hide their true (likely much lower) value