Hi, I have a transmasc boyfriend and am part of the LGBTQ+ alliance. However I started my first year of college and encountered uneducated men who just did not believe that trans people had their rights under attack. One of my friends even told my trans woman friend that she had more rights than him. How or what can you do to help others become educated without “debating trans existence” or starting an argument? Thank you.
There is a stark difference between the average opinion in online spaces and in real life. Most people will just flat out not care. Talk about golf or the weather or something.
Tbh, I don’t know much beyond “transgender people exist”. No idea about any nuances, the exact kinds of transgender, the differences etc. There seems to be a lot more to it than “trans men/women”, and I feel a bit ignorant trying to make sense of terms like “asexual” by their dictionary definitions.
I’ve so far been living by the motto “be a decent person”, considering myself open-minded and tolerant, but if there are good sources of information with an overview of all this, please drop me a link.
deleted by creator
That’s a solid policy. I apply it to most humans and so far it has worked out ok for me.
You can lead a horse to water, but you can’t make it drink.
I think it’s fine to want to educate the undereducated, but the reality is they’ll never learn unless they want to learn. So when they say something ignorant, you can just say that hasn’t been your experience.
If they ask for more you can share your experience. If they’re still interested then you can open it up to the broader national or global narrative.
I feel for you and your loved ones and I hope you have success finding and building allies in your community.
deleted by creator
I think this is solid advice, for more topics than just trans debates. I personally try to stick to speaking from my perspective, i.e. “I had no clue about the experience trans persons have, so I kept an open mind and tried to understand their perspectives on that matter.”
I don’t entirely agree. I think there’s plenty of people who will listen and will realize that they aren’t well informed. Just… There’s even more people that will be like talking to a brick wall and you have to be aware of that so you don’t get burnt out. Some people need to be treated like a lost cause. Trying to convince them will just depress you. It’s also perfectly valid to not bother trying to convince anyone because of this.
But there absolutely are some people who will listen and change their mind. Myself, I was that way, growing up in a small town echo chamber and learning an embarrassingly large amount when I went to university. I’ve also personally convinced several others myself. But it can feel like depressingly few people are like that. I think because most people that you see who are uneducated are willfully so. These kinda social issues have been in the limelight for a while, so few people are unaware of them anymore.
I think the people who are most likely to change their minds are those who were previously in echo chambers (such as from rural areas or less progressive countries). Anyone else has already had too many chances to change.
deleted by creator
First, you’ve got to accept the fact that they’re probably not bad people. Maybe not even dumb or bigoted…
If your parents taught you that house cats kill more people than car crashes, and a few times a week your dad is reading the paper and tells you stuff like “tsk, you’re aunt’s best friend from college was paralyzed last week. A cat attacked her in her sleep. Cut straight through her hip. Her son scared it off, but they say she’ll never walk again”
They’ve never seen a cat, everyone in their town says the same things about them. Maybe one or two people claim it’s just a weird superstition, that they’ve met a cat and it was harmless… But only behind closed doors.
If they go off to college, see a cat, and throw a brick at it, you’re going to think they’re psychotic. If you start screaming at them, they’re going to get angry and think you’re the psycho.
Humans only know what they’ve learned and been taught. Plus, the majority of us are wired to trust the group consensus over their thoughts. Stuff like Fox news is their source of truth - it’s what their parents and friends believed, if you have an argument and pull up their news clip and you’ve won.
Now as tempting as it is to respond with disgust and dismissal, you have to remember - their warped sense of truth is based around the consensus of the group. If you attack them for spouting harmful nonsense, you’re not coming at them as a member of the group.
And just like a cult, they’ve probably been told stuff like “they” have everyone tricked, or you’re one of “them” attacking them for telling the truth.
If you want to change their minds, you have to come at them as a friend.
You could ask them indirect questions with clinical answers, and find hard dispute sources of data. Just easy things that don’t refute their stance, and have simple answers
Like, what percentage of people do you think are trans? It’s something like .2-5% IIRC. Give that to them as a number in city or county you’re in. Ask them how many high school athletes are trans - it’s an absurdly low number, because surprise surprise, trans people generally don’t like being called out for their gender identity.
Let them connect the dots themselves, let them go in circles trying to figure out if such a small group really has that much power, or if it’s really that big a great to make laws banning them from sports when every high school trans student athlete in the country could fit in a moderately sized room
The other angle is emotional vulnerability. Tell them personal stories about people being hateful, or of how their comments hurt you personally.
Once they’re open to examining their beliefs, meeting a trans person is a pretty straightforward way to make it real. Do it too immediately it might work out, or they might think (or say) “well they’re not really trans, they’re a normal person”…
It takes time to break programming like that - and make no mistake, this was a systemic plan now that black and gay people are no longer as acceptable to hate on as they used to be. This is exactly why the media needs to be independent - but follow the money and you’ll see most of it can be traced back to a few billionaires with their own agenda
Actually interacting with a trans person is a pretty simple way to change their stance on the matter, but I wouldn’t put my SO in a position before I was confident they’d be at least civil… I said in the beginning, they’re probably not bad people - some people will do mental gymnastics to avoid the realization that they’re wrong and have been being really shitty
Whether it’s incels, bigots, or fascists, you have to be endlessly patient and give them a path back. They’re all cults spreading beliefs that isolate and prevent connections outside the group - incels are a great case study, literally every single one of their beliefs about women guarantee they’ll have only short, disturbing interactions with them. If they learned pickup instead of how to rant to someone you don’t see them as a person and think the government should force them into sex slavery, most of them (sooner or later) would no longer be incels.
Hate the ideas, be indirect with firmly held beliefs, and (most of all) offer them a path to rejoin larger society
I like to figuratively give people shovels and let them dig themselves into a hole. A lot of people I talk to don’t really have good evidence, they’ve just been convinced by someone louder than them.
Ask genuine questions, not debate me bro style, for explanations. If they’re open minded, maybe they’ll question things. If they’re closed minded, you were never gonna get anywhere with them.
To say something controversial: maybe listen to what they have to say and try to understand why they think what they think, instead of assuming that you’re automatically right and just need to educate them.
I think its pretty weird if you say trans people are treated equally, let alone more rights. It’s still a societal problem we have in a lot of places and in my experience all I meet that are trans have some sucky times because of other people…
To be fair there is an entire month dedicated to LGBT pride.
There wouldn’t need to be a month dedicated to pride if lgbt people weren’t discriminated against.
I’m just starting what the average person sees.
So it makes it equal because they get a “month”. I get it. You probably don’t know a lot of these people and i didnt use to either. But when speaking about their life experience, they have been shunned from most friend groups and yeah they all chill with like minded people cause you know there aren’t any bigots there.
I get that if you were like me and you really arent a bigot, that it is hard to see the (daily) struggles and think well I dont see any discrimination. But like most people can amend to is that most have more struggles because they are of the lgbtq+ group.
Exactly. Most of us can’t really know about it because we don’t see it everyday.
All of my LGBTQ friends have a story or another of a scary situation, and I live in a very LGBTQ friendly place.
Saying there’s no discrimination against them is either misinformed, or burying your head in the sand.
The post was asking about normies and I was relating what should be expected and the thought process there in.
Thats the issue though. They dont think, Ive tried asking them about stuff and they’ll parrot things like “puberty blockers kill people.” then I show them that study was wrong and they just dont believe me lol.
I think it’s worth asking, on a case by case basis, if a conversation with that person is going to be productive. Are they open at all to changing their mind about any aspect of the topic (and are you)? If not, then all you can do with that person is be an example of a good, reasonably sane person who disagrees with them. Just my 2¢.
You are right though. Always be open for change in discussions. How else will we ever be truthful to ourselves and others. But this doesnt feel like a discussion.
Being a dick to someone will never be okay, except when they are being a dick. Conservative, progressive or whatever, idc. But its just a dick’s opinion to hate trans.
So your only example is a strawman nobody believes?
People actually use “puberty blockers are harmful” as an actual argument so I dont think its that hard to believe.
Removed by mod
Lol you’ve already pivoted your argument. Seems you’re the one incapable of good faith interaction
deleted by creator
Anti-trans rhetoric drives up suicide rates in trans people. My personal moral code is incompatable with participating.
Not judging your personal moral code, that’s up to you.
From what I see here for example: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5649411/
There’s no good data apart from: Suicide rates are higher than in general population and remain higher than general population even after surgery.
You could try dropping the condescending tone. Just because someone disagrees with you doesn’t mean he is uneducated.
I would also recommend being polite and using the charity principle. You generally won’t change someone’s mind by berating him.
A lot of the beliefs surrounding this issue are decade old lies that have been repeated so often that they’ve become the “truth”.
Best example is the classic rhetoric of public bathrooms.
You might have heard that “Trans people just want to rape little girls in public bathrooms”.
The fact is, the only instance of a trans person ever raping someone in a bathroom I could find was at a women’s prison. Prison bathrooms have a certain reputation regarding rape, so let’s leave it at that.
Meanwhile, trans people are 4 times more likely to be victims of rape than the general population, and I was able to find multiple instances of trans people getting raped in bathrooms by cis people. Let that sink in for a moment.
Getting people to realize these old lies are just that, old shitty lies, has given me some amount of success in educating people in real-life debates.
