Although how the cat was killed is unknown, according to the Magistrate Findings of Fact from the Carteret County Courthouse. Officials have video evidence in addition to Box initially lying to the deputy about the incident.

…

Box was also charged with misdemeanor Local Ordinance-Free Text for intentionally discharging a firearm outside of the corporate limits of any municipality within the county, within 400 feet of any building consisting of five or more residence, and within 400 feet of a public school.

total mystery there. a total mystery. however could he have killed that cat?