Reposting this from Qasim Rashid, esq. on Mastodon.

(I do know this is discoverable from Mastodon but heck consider it a boost).

  • Colombo@kbin.social
    2319·
    1 year ago

    It’s a bit more nuanced

    That is not more nuanced those are plain facts. OP is plainly lying.

    She is accused and jailed for voluntarily being a part of a smuggling operation, even when she was explicitly told not to do so by the Italian government.

    Compared to completely normal rescue efforts when a boat or plane capsize, when workers are trapped in a mine, when someone is lost in the mountains, or when a bunch of nobodies are taken hostage by a criminal organisation, be it local or abroad.

    Again, this is not nuance, those are commonly known facts that OP is lying about.

    • twelve@sh.itjust.worksEnglish
      181·
      1 year ago

      No, it’s nuanced. People smuggling worked like this… They would call her (and/or other NGO) and say “we just dropped x people in the sea at these coordinated, bye!”. She would go and pick them up (she would not make any money out of this).

      What the xenophobic party that was (and kinda is) in power wanted is to her ignore the heads up and let people die in the sea. Because all that party promised to his (debatable) electors is more death in the sea (to scare the other migrants).

      Also all this is polical because the vast majority of illegal immigration is through Balkans anyway

      • ProcurementCat@feddit.deEnglish
        181·
        1 year ago

        They would call her (and/or other NGO) and say “we just dropped x people in the sea at these coordinated, bye!”. She would go and pick them up (she would not make any money out of this).

        The crucial part about that: Captains at sea are required by law to save people or assist vessels that are about to capsize. If she ignored such a call (as the Italian government tells her to), she’d commit a crime. She’d also be liable and could be sued by the survivors or the relatives of the deceased.

        She literally did what the law forces her to do, and what the Italian coast guard should be doing but isn’t.